From out of the city the dying groan, and the soul of the wounded cries for help; yet God charges no one with wrong.
English Standard Version (ESV)
The verse highlights a stark contrast: the loud, desperate cries of the suffering within the city walls go unnoticed by God, not because He doesn't see, but because He "charges no one with wrong." This implies that while human systems and individuals are failing to act justly, God's inaction isn't a lack of care, but rather a deliberate withholding of immediate judgment, leaving the ultimate accounting to Himself.
From out of the city the dying groan, and the soul of the wounded cries for help; yet God charges no one with wrong.
English Standard Version (ESV)
Job continues his vivid portrayal of wicked people, shifting from rural abuses to the injustices happening within city walls. He describes the audible suffering of those crushed by oppression, their cries of pain and desperation echoing, yet notes that God doesn't immediately intervene or punish these perpetrators. This sets up Job's larger argument that prosperity and suffering don't always reflect divine justice in this life.
We often imagine suffering is confined to remote, desolate places. But Job points us to a place we know well: the city.
Job 24:12 paints a stark picture, moving the scene of oppression from the countryside to the city. This isn't just about physical suffering; it's about the deep, gut-wrenching groans of people crushed by injustice within the very walls meant to provide safety and order.
The Sound of Suffering
Job uses the city setting to show that oppression isn't an anomaly of the wilderness; it thrives even where society is supposed to be functioning. It’s a reminder that suffering can be hidden in plain sight, often masked by the daily routines of urban life.
Job presents a heart-wrenching paradox: the cries of the suffering ascend, yet God seems to take no action.
The most challenging part of Job 24:12 is the final phrase: "yet God charges no one with wrong." This isn't just an observation; it's a theological wrestling match. Job sees immense suffering and hears the desperate cries for help, but he doesn't see immediate divine intervention or punishment for the oppressors.
Ask a follow-up
Wrestling with Divine Justice
Job isn't saying God is unjust. He's expressing the profound difficulty of reconciling innocent suffering with the belief in an all-powerful, all-good God who is sovereign over human affairs. This reflects a tension many believers grapple with when facing deep injustice.
Understand the original words
nephesh · Hebrew Noun
The core immaterial aspect of a human being; the seat of life, emotions, desires, and the capacity for relationship with God. In this context, it emphasizes the intense, conscious suffering and longing of the afflicted.
tiphlih · Hebrew Noun
To be held accountable, corrected, or disciplined for an offense. Theologically, it implies an authoritative examination of one's actions and the imposition of a verdict or judgment.
This passage echoes Job's lament, describing how the psalmist's faith was shaken by observing the unpunished prosperity of the wicked, who seem to mock God and cause suffering to others.
Jeremiah 22:13-17This prophetic passage condemns rulers who oppress their people, build unjust kingdoms, and ignore the cries of the poor and wounded, highlighting a similar pattern of injustice and God's eventual judgment.
Luke 18:7-8Jesus tells the parable of the persistent widow, emphasizing that even when human systems fail and God's justice seems delayed, He will eventually hear the cries of the oppressed and bring about justice for them.
Ecclesiastes 8:10-11This wisdom literature passage directly addresses the issue of seeing wicked people buried and honored while their evil deeds go unpunished, reflecting the same frustration Job expresses about God's apparent inaction.
wesleyJob 24:12: "Men groan from out of the city, and the soul of the wounded crieth out: yet God layeth not folly to them."
24:12 Groan - Under grievous oppressions. Soul - The life or blood of those who are wounded to death, as this word properly signifies, crieth aloud to God for vengeance. Yet - Yet God doth not punish them.
ellicottJob 24:12: "Men groan from out of the city, and the soul of the wounded crieth out: yet God layeth not folly to them."
(12) Men groan from out of the city. —Here a survey of the oppressions wrought within the city walls is taken. Yet God layeth not folly to them.—That is, to those who are the cause of their wrongs, their oppressors.
The verse highlights a stark contrast: the loud, desperate cries of the suffering within the city walls go unnoticed by God, not because He doesn't see, but because He "charges no one with wrong." This implies that while human systems and individuals are failing to act justly, God's inaction isn't a lack of care, but rather a deliberate withholding of immediate judgment, leaving the ultimate accounting to Himself.
Job continues his vivid portrayal of wicked people, shifting from rural abuses to the injustices happening within city walls. He describes the audible suffering of those crushed by oppression, their cries of pain and desperation echoing, yet notes that God doesn't immediately intervene or punish these perpetrators. This sets up Job's larger argument that prosperity and suffering don't always reflect divine justice in this life.
Job continues his vivid portrayal of wicked people, shifting from rural abuses to the injustices happening within city walls. He describes the audible suffering of those crushed by oppression, their cries of pain and desperation echoing, yet notes that God doesn't immediately intervene or punish these perpetrators. This sets up Job's larger argument that prosperity and suffering don't always reflect divine justice in this life.
"From out of the city the dying groan, and the soul of the wounded cries for help; yet God charges no one with wrong." — The verse highlights a stark contrast: the loud, desperate cries of the suffering within the city walls go unnoticed by God, not because He doesn't see, but because He "charges no one with wrong." Th…
Get the original Greek and Hebrew, verse-by-verse context, and related passages inside the app.
Last reviewed October 2026