Mark 2:21
No one sews a piece of unshrunk cloth on an old garment. If he does, the patch tears away from it, the new from the old, and a worse tear is made.
English Standard Version (ESV)
This page isn't yet indexed by search engines.
Jesus isn't just talking about sewing; he's highlighting how attempting to blend the old ways (like strict fasting traditions) with his new, grace-filled message will only lead to disaster. It’s like trying to fix a worn-out garment with a brand-new patch – the stiff, unshrunk fabric will pull and tear the fragile old cloth, making the whole thing worse. This shows that God's new work in Christ can't be simply tacked onto existing religious systems; it requires a completely new approach.
Jesus responds to a question about why his disciples don't fast like John the Baptist's and the Pharisees' disciples by sharing two parables. The first likens his disciples to wedding guests who rejoice in the bridegroom's presence, contrasting it with the sorrow that will later necessitate fasting. This verse, the second parable, illustrates that the new, vibrant life Jesus brings cannot be superficially attached to the rigid, outdated religious practices of the day.
Why would Jesus compare his disciples to old clothes and his teachings to patches?
Jesus uses a vivid analogy from everyday life to explain why his new way of life can't simply be added to the old religious systems.
The Problem of the Patch
Imagine an old, worn-out robe. It has its own familiar feel, its own history. Now, imagine sewing a brand-new, stiff piece of unshrunk cloth onto it. What happens when you wash it, or even just move around? The new cloth, not having been washed and shrunk yet, is rigid and strong in a different way than the old fabric. It pulls on the old, weaker threads, and instead of fixing the tear, it rips the old garment even more. The result? A bigger, worse tear than before.
This wasn't just about sewing; it was a powerful statement about the radical newness of God's kingdom Jesus was introducing. It wasn't meant to be awkwardly attached to the brittle, man-made traditions of the past. That kind of mixing would only lead to destruction.
Ask a follow-up
Ask Sola things like:
Live chat about Mark 2:21 is available in the Sola app.
The religious leaders wanted to blend Jesus' radical message with their own practices. Jesus said 'no'.
Jesus' ministry wasn't about tweaking the existing religious system; it was about bringing something entirely new – the Kingdom of God.
A New Reality
Jesus is the Bridegroom (Mark 2:19-20), and his presence signifies a time of celebration, not mourning. The disciples' joy and new way of life under his direct influence couldn't be forced into the rigid, somber framework of the Pharisees' fasting and traditions. Trying to do so would be like that ill-fitting patch, creating a 'worse tear.'
This parable wasn't a dismissal of the past entirely, but a declaration that the new covenant in Christ is fundamentally different. It's not an upgrade or an add-on to the old; it's a new reality that requires a new way of living, thinking, and relating to God. The old garment represents the brittle, tradition-bound religious life that couldn't contain the vibrant, life-giving power of Jesus' message.
This parable emerges from a direct confrontation with religious leaders who question Jesus' followers for not adhering to their traditions of fasting. Jesus uses the imagery of mending clothes to illustrate why his new way of following God cannot simply be stitched onto the old religious systems.
c. 27-30 AD
Jesus' early Galilean ministry begins
Jesus begins his public ministry in Galilee, gathering disciples and teaching with new authority. His ministry is characterized by miracles and a challenge to prevailing religious norms.
c. 27-30 AD— this verse
Jesus calls Levi (Matthew)
Jesus calls Matthew, a tax collector, to follow him. This event leads to a feast where Jesus dines with tax collectors and sinners, sparking criticism from religious leaders.
c. 27-30 AD
Debates over fasting and Sabbath observance
Jesus and his disciples face challenges from religious authorities regarding their practices, particularly their lack of fasting and their actions on the Sabbath. This leads to Jesus explaining his mission through parables.
c. 30-33 AD
Jesus' ministry intensifies
Jesus' teachings and actions continue to provoke controversy. The parables in Mark 2, including the one about the new patch, are spoken during this period of increasing tension.
This passage appears parallel to Mark 2:21, featuring Jesus using the same analogy about new patches on old garments to illustrate a point about his disciples' practices.
Luke 5:36Luke includes this analogy as well, alongside the one about new wine and old wineskins, to explain why Jesus' disciples did not follow the fasting traditions of the Pharisees and John the Baptist.
Galatians 3:3Paul uses a similar idea of starting with the spiritual and then trying to perfect it with the physical ('in the flesh') to show that such a combination leads to weakness and failure, echoing the concept of the new ruining the old.
Romans 6:19Paul discusses the 'weaker' state of believers when they first come to faith, likening it to not being able to handle strong spiritual truths immediately, which parallels the idea of new cloth being too strong for an old garment.
pooleMark 2:21: "No man also seweth a piece of new cloth on an old garment: else the new piece that filled it up taketh away from the old, and the rent is made worse."
See Poole on "Mark 2:21"
gillMark 2:21: "No man also seweth a piece of new cloth on an old garment: else the new piece that filled it up taketh away from the old, and the rent is made worse."
No man also seweth a piece of new cloth, The traditions of the elders are meant, particularly concerning eating and drinking, and fasting, things before spoken of; and which occasioned this parable, and which were new things in comparison of the commands of God: some of them were of very short standing, devised in, that age; and most,…
Jesus isn't just talking about sewing; he's highlighting how attempting to blend the old ways (like strict fasting traditions) with his new, grace-filled message will only lead to disaster. It’s like trying to fix a worn-out garment with a brand-new patch – the stiff, unshrunk fabric will pull and tear the fragile old cloth, making the whole thing worse. This shows that God's new work in Christ can't be simply tacked onto existing religious systems; it requires a completely new approach.
Jesus responds to a question about why his disciples don't fast like John the Baptist's and the Pharisees' disciples by sharing two parables. The first likens his disciples to wedding guests who rejoice in the bridegroom's presence, contrasting it with the sorrow that will later necessitate fasting. This verse, the second parable, illustrates that the new, vibrant life Jesus brings cannot be superficially attached to the rigid, outdated religious practices of the day.
Jesus responds to a question about why his disciples don't fast like John the Baptist's and the Pharisees' disciples by sharing two parables. The first likens his disciples to wedding guests who rejoice in the bridegroom's presence, contrasting it with the sorrow that will later necessitate fasting. This verse, the second parable, illustrates that the new, vibrant life Jesus brings cannot be superficially attached to the rigid, outdated religious practices of the day.
"No one sews a piece of unshrunk cloth on an old garment. If he does, the patch tears away from it, the new from the old, and a worse tear is made." — Jesus isn't just talking about sewing; he's highlighting how attempting to blend the old ways (like strict fasting traditions) with his new, grace-filled message will only lead to disaster. It’s like…
Get the original Greek and Hebrew, verse-by-verse context, and related passages inside the app.
