Will man rob God? Yet you are robbing me. But you say, ‘How have we robbed you?’ In your tithes and contributions. You are cursed with a curse, for you are robbing me, the whole nation of you.
English Standard Version (ESV)
The people's question, "How have we robbed you?" isn't just a question of ignorance; it reveals a shocking disconnect where they don't even recognize their withholding of God's portion as theft. God's sharp reply pinpoints that their failure to give tithes and offerings was actively robbing Him, not just neglecting a religious duty.
Will man rob God? Yet you are robbing me. But you say, ‘How have we robbed you?’ In your tithes and contributions. You are cursed with a curse, for you are robbing me, the whole nation of you.
English Standard Version (ESV)
After God has declared his love for them and challenged their ungrateful response, the people ask how they can return or repent. God immediately confronts them with a stark accusation: they are robbing Him by withholding the tithes and offerings designated for the temple and its ministers. This isn't a forgotten past offense, but an ongoing pattern of sacrilege that has disrupted worship and impoverished the Levites.
Malachi doesn't just accuse; he asks a rhetorical question that demands a gut reaction. What does it mean to 'rob' God, and why is it presented as so unthinkable?
The prophet starts with a bold question: "Will man rob God?" It's a loaded question, implying that the very idea is audacious, almost unthinkable. Yet, immediately after, God declares, "Yet you are robbing me." This contrast highlights the shocking reality of the people's actions. They are treating God, the Creator and Sustainer of all things, as if He were a mere mortal they could cheat. This isn't just about money; it's about a fundamental disrespect for God's sovereignty and provision. They've withheld what rightfully belongs to God, thereby diminishing His honor and neglecting His appointed worship and service.
God's point is that these tithes and offerings weren't just optional gifts; they were designated portions of their prosperity that belonged to Him by divine appointment. To withhold them was to steal from God's own treasury, essential for the support of the Levites and the maintenance of temple worship.
The people's response isn't outright denial, but a defiant question: 'How have we robbed you?' What does this reveal about their spiritual state?
The people’s question, 'How have we robbed you?' is not a sincere inquiry seeking understanding. It's a question born of spiritual dullness and perhaps even arrogance. They are either genuinely oblivious to their sin or pretending to be, unable to see how withholding what belongs to God constitutes theft. They've become so accustomed to their disobedience that the very idea of it being 'robbing God' doesn't even register.
God’s direct answer, 'In your tithes and contributions,' cuts through their ignorance or defiance. This points to a critical disconnect: they had lost sight of the divine claim on their material wealth. The tithes and offerings were tangible expressions of their covenant relationship with God, acknowledging Him as the source of all they had. By failing to give these, they weren’t just failing an economic requirement; they were severing a spiritual connection and disrespecting God’s rule over their lives.
Ask a follow-up
Understand the original words
qaba' · Hebrew Verb
The act of stealing or defrauding. In a theological sense, it refers to withholding what rightfully belongs to God, whether it be worship, obedience, or resources.
ma'aser · Hebrew Noun
A tenth part of one's increase, dedicated to God as a recognition of His ownership of all things and for the support of His service and house.
terumah · Hebrew Noun
An offering or portion set apart for a sacred purpose; often refers to gifts or contributions given to God to honor Him.
arar · Hebrew Verb/Noun
A state of divine judgment or removal of favor due to disobedience. It represents the judicial consequence of breaking God's covenant.
Malachi's sharp rebuke about robbing God through withheld tithes and offerings points to a systemic failure that had plagued Israel even after their return from exile, a problem Nehemiah had already had to address.
c. 1400 BC
Mosaic Law Establishes Tithes
The Law given through Moses details requirements for tithes and offerings, dedicating portions of agricultural produce and livestock to the Levites and priests for their support and temple service.
c. 586 BC
Destruction of Jerusalem and Temple
The Babylonians conquer Judah, destroy Solomon's Temple in Jerusalem, and exile a significant portion of the population, disrupting established religious practices and the Levites' and priests' livelihoods.
c. 516 BC
Dedication of the Second Temple
After the return from Babylonian exile, the Second Temple is completed and dedicated, re-establishing a central place for worship and sacrifice, though the glory of the first temple was not matched.
c. 445-433 BC— this verse
Nehemiah Reforms Tithing
Upon returning to Jerusalem, Nehemiah discovers that the people have ceased bringing their tithes and offerings, leading him to re-establish the practice and ensure the Levites and priests are supported.
This passage establishes the principle of the tithe as belonging to the Lord, highlighting that withholding it is directly robbing God of what He has set apart.
Numbers 18:21-24It explains the purpose of the tithe: it's given to the Levites for their service, showing that defrauding them is equivalent to defrauding God, as He is the one who ordained this system.
Nehemiah 13:10-12This shows a historical parallel where the people and leaders were neglecting to bring their tithes and contributions, leading to the support of temple service and Levites breaking down, mirroring Malachi's rebuke.
Proverbs 22:23This proverb warns against oppressing the poor and the needy, which can be extended to the principle of not withholding what is due to God and His servants, lest they cry out.
Romans 2:22Paul links sacrilege with other serious sins, implying that robbing God through withheld tithes and offerings is a grave offense against the divine law and order.
bensonMalachi 3:8: "Will a man rob God? Yet ye have robbed me. But ye say, Wherein have we robbed thee? In tithes and offerings."
Malachi 3:8-9 . Will a man rob God — Grotius reads, “Would any one dare to rob his judges as ye have robbed me?” the word rendered God sometimes meaning judges or magistrates. Some others render the clause, Is it right that God should be robbed (or defrauded) by man? Here God gives them an answer to their question in the foregoing verse, Wherein shall we return; or, repent…
clarkeMalachi 3:8: "Will a man rob God? Yet ye have robbed me. But ye say, Wherein have we robbed thee? In tithes and offerings."
Will a man rob God? - Here is one point on which ye are guilty; ye withhold the tithes and offerings from the temple of God, so that the Divine worship is neglected.
The people's question, "How have we robbed you?" isn't just a question of ignorance; it reveals a shocking disconnect where they don't even recognize their withholding of God's portion as theft. God's sharp reply pinpoints that their failure to give tithes and offerings was actively robbing Him, not just neglecting a religious duty.
After God has declared his love for them and challenged their ungrateful response, the people ask how they can return or repent. God immediately confronts them with a stark accusation: they are robbing Him by withholding the tithes and offerings designated for the temple and its ministers. This isn't a forgotten past offense, but an ongoing pattern of sacrilege that has disrupted worship and impoverished the Levites.
After God has declared his love for them and challenged their ungrateful response, the people ask how they can return or repent. God immediately confronts them with a stark accusation: they are robbing Him by withholding the tithes and offerings designated for the temple and its ministers. This isn't a forgotten past offense, but an ongoing pattern of sacrilege that has disrupted worship and impoverished the Levites.
"Will man rob God? Yet you are robbing me. But you say, ‘How have we robbed you?’ In your tithes and contributions. You are cursed with a curse, for you are robbing me, the whole nation of you." — The people's question, "How have we robbed you?" isn't just a question of ignorance; it reveals a shocking disconnect where they don't even recognize their withholding of God's portion as theft. God'…
Get the original Greek and Hebrew, verse-by-verse context, and related passages inside the app.
Last reviewed October 2026