But you say, “Why does he not?” Because the LORD was witness between you and the wife of your youth, to whom you have been faithless, though she is your companion and your wife by covenant.
English Standard Version (ESV)
This passage reveals a subtle but powerful point: God isn't just observing their unfaithfulness; He was the very witness to the vows exchanged at the beginning of these marriages. Their treacherous actions weren't just a personal betrayal of their wives, but a violation of a covenant God Himself sanctioned and stands as a witness to, making their sin deeply offensive to Him.
But you say, “Why does he not?” Because the LORD was witness between you and the wife of your youth, to whom you have been faithless, though she is your companion and your wife by covenant.
English Standard Version (ESV)
The people are questioning God's apparent indifference to their offerings, prompting the prophet Malachi to reveal the deeper issue: their treacherous treatment of their wives. God had witnessed the original marriage vows between these men and their young wives, vows sealed by a sacred covenant. Despite these solemn commitments and the companionship built over years, the men were now betraying their wives, casting them aside, which invalidated their worship.
Ever feel like your commitments are a private matter between you and the other person? Malachi reminds us that some vows are witnessed by more than just the individuals involved.
When the people of Judah question why God is displeased, the prophet Malachi points to a profound truth: God Himself is the witness to their marriage vows.
A Sacred Contract
God didn't just create marriage; He sanctifies it. When a man and woman enter into marriage, especially "the wife of your youth," they are making a covenant before God. He is the ultimate witness to this sacred agreement, seeing both the promises made and their subsequent violation.
More Than Just a Legal Bond
This divine witnessing elevates marriage beyond a simple contract. It means God is intimately aware of the fidelity and faithfulness (or lack thereof) within the union. He sees the betrayal of a spouse who was chosen in the freshness of youth, a companion meant for life.
Malachi confronts the people about breaking faith with their spouses. What makes this betrayal particularly grievous in God's eyes?
The sin being exposed is not just a breach of contract, but a profound act of treachery against a specific person: 'the wife of your youth.'
A Companion of Youth
This phrase carries immense weight. It refers to the woman a man married when his own affections were pure and strong, and when her best years were before them. She shared in his early life, his hopes, and his struggles.
Ask a follow-up
A Covenant Undone
She is also called 'your companion' and 'the wife of your covenant.' This highlights that she was more than just a partner; she was an intimate associate, a ' ' of his life. The marriage covenant was a solemn pledge before God, implying a bond of loyalty and shared future.
The Aggravation of Betrayal
To betray such a companion, the wife of his covenant, especially one from his youth, is a monstrous crime. It signifies a deep disregard for shared history, divine sanction, and the very essence of loyalty. This perfidy is a primary reason God rejects their offerings.
The people cry, 'Why?' Malachi's response reveals a pattern of denial and a deep-seated hardness of heart.
The question 'Wherefore?' (or 'Why?') isn't an earnest plea for understanding from the people of Judah; it's a sign of their stubbornness and their attempt to evade responsibility.
The Sceptical Objection
Malachi has encountered this before. Like spoiled children or defiant rebels, they refuse to acknowledge their guilt. When God's judgment or displeasure is evident (in this case, their unacceptable offerings), their immediate reaction is to question the divine reasoning, acting ignorant or innocent.
The Prophet's Direct Answer
The prophet doesn't engage in their evasion. He directly confronts their sin: their faithlessness in marriage. This specific, glaring vice is presented as a clear indicator of their overall hypocrisy and their disregard for God's covenant.
Shamelessness Before God
This questioning, this attempt to 'excuse' their perfidy, demonstrates a shocking hardness. They dare to 'answer God' and 'repel all warnings.' Their sin isn't just the betrayal of their wives, but the accompanying shamelessness in the face of God's prophetic word.
Understand the original words
ed · Hebrew Noun
One who observes an event or relationship and testifies to the truth of it. When God is a witness, He serves as the ultimate guarantor and judge of the integrity of a vow or covenant.
berit · Hebrew Noun
A binding, solemn agreement between two parties that carries divine sanction and obligations. In marriage, it signifies a sacred, permanent commitment established before God.
The people of Malachi's day were treating marriage, a covenant witnessed by God from creation, with casual disregard, divorcing their wives for selfish reasons and breaking solemn vows. This betrayal of their 'wife of youth' was a profound offense to God, undermining the very order He established.
~1400 BC
Institution of Marriage
God institutes marriage in Eden, establishing it as a lifelong, exclusive union between one man and one woman, 'one flesh.' This sets the foundational covenantal understanding of marriage.
c. 1000 BC
Solomon's Wisdom Literature
Proverbs emphasizes the value of the wife of one's youth and the sanctity of the marriage covenant, warning against infidelity and divorce.
c. 700 BC
Prophetic Warnings
Prophets like Jeremiah warn against unfaithfulness and broken covenants, lamenting the moral decay within Israel.
c. 450 BC— this verse
Malachi's Rebuke of Israel
Malachi delivers God's final message to Judah after the return from exile, confronting their spiritual apathy, corrupt worship, and social injustices, including infidelity.
This passage lays the foundation for marriage as a divine institution where a man and woman become 'one flesh,' underscoring the sacred and unbreakable bond that Malachi's audience was violating.
Proverbs 2:17This verse calls marriage 'the covenant of God,' highlighting the profound spiritual commitment that was disregarded by those who dealt treacherously with their wives.
Jeremiah 2:2Jeremiah reminds Israel of their 'early love' and 'love as a bride,' drawing a parallel to the betrayal of youthful vows that Malachi is addressing, specifically in the context of marriage.
Matthew 19:6Jesus directly quotes Genesis 2:24, reinforcing the indissoluble nature of marriage and condemning divorce, which directly relates to the 'dealing treacherously' mentioned in Malachi.
Genesis 31:50In this narrative, Laban invokes God as a witness to a covenant between himself and Jacob, showing how God's role as a witness to agreements, including marriage, was a well-understood concept, making the betrayal of the marriage covenant a grave offense.
clarkeMalachi 2:14: "Yet ye say, Wherefore? Because the LORD hath been witness between thee and the wife of thy youth, against whom thou hast dealt treacherously: yet is she thy companion, and the wife of thy covenant."
Ye say, Wherefore? - Is the Lord angry with us? Because ye have been witness of the contract made between the parties; and when the lawless husband divorced his wife, the wife of his youth, his companion, and the unite of his covenant, ye did not execute on him the discipline of the l…
barnesMalachi 2:14: "Yet ye say, Wherefore? Because the LORD hath been witness between thee and the wife of thy youth, against whom thou hast dealt treacherously: yet is she thy companion, and the wife of thy covenant."
And ye say, Wherefore? - They again act the innocent, or half-ignorant. What had they to do with their wives' womanly tears? He who knows the hearts of all was Himself the witness between them and the wife of youth of each; her to whom, in the first freshness of life and their young h…
This passage reveals a subtle but powerful point: God isn't just observing their unfaithfulness; He was the very witness to the vows exchanged at the beginning of these marriages. Their treacherous actions weren't just a personal betrayal of their wives, but a violation of a covenant God Himself sanctioned and stands as a witness to, making their sin deeply offensive to Him.
The people are questioning God's apparent indifference to their offerings, prompting the prophet Malachi to reveal the deeper issue: their treacherous treatment of their wives. God had witnessed the original marriage vows between these men and their young wives, vows sealed by a sacred covenant. Despite these solemn commitments and the companionship built over years, the men were now betraying their wives, casting them aside, which invalidated their worship.
The people are questioning God's apparent indifference to their offerings, prompting the prophet Malachi to reveal the deeper issue: their treacherous treatment of their wives. God had witnessed the original marriage vows between these men and their young wives, vows sealed by a sacred covenant. Despite these solemn commitments and the companionship built over years, the men were now betraying their wives, casting them aside, which invalidated their worship.
"But you say, “Why does he not?” Because the LORD was witness between you and the wife of your youth, to whom you have been faithless, though she is your companion and your wife by covenant." — This passage reveals a subtle but powerful point: God isn't just observing their unfaithfulness; He was the very witness to the vows exchanged at the beginning of these marriages. Their treacherous…
Get the original Greek and Hebrew, verse-by-verse context, and related passages inside the app.
Last reviewed October 2026