Luke 24:17-18
And he said to them, “What is this conversation that you are holding with each other as you walk?” And they stood still, looking sad. Then one of them, named Cleopas, answered him, “Are you the only visitor to Jerusalem who does not know the things that have happened there in these days?”
English Standard Version (ESV)
This page isn't yet indexed by search engines.
The phrasing "What is this conversation that you are holding with each other" highlights not just the words they're exchanging, but the very act of them throwing ideas back and forth. Jesus is observing their shared, pained dialogue as they walk, noticing how their sorrow shapes the very substance of their interaction.
Two disciples are walking away from Jerusalem, deeply disheartened and confused after Jesus' crucifixion, their hopes for Israel's redemption dashed. As they discuss these events, a stranger joins them, and Jesus, appearing unrecognized, inquires about the source of their sorrowful conversation.
Ever feel like God is distant when you're hurting the most? You're not alone. Even Jesus' closest followers didn't recognize Him when He was right beside them.
Imagine walking with someone you deeply admire, someone whose life and teachings have shaped you. Now imagine that very person is walking with you, but you don't know it's them. That's the reality for these two disciples on the road to Emmaus. Jesus, fresh from the tomb, joins them.
The 'Why' Behind Not Knowing
Luke points out, 'their eyes were held' (Luke 24:16). This wasn't a failure on their part, but a divine orchestration. God intentionally veiled their recognition, allowing them the space to process their grief and confusion without the immediate relief (or perhaps the full weight) of His presence being obvious. This reminds us that God's presence isn't always felt in a way we expect, especially in our deepest sorrow.
What do you 'throw back and forth' when life hits hard? The disciples were locked in a conversation of grief, and Jesus gently probed its depths.
Jesus asks, 'What is this conversation that you are holding with each other?' The Greek word used here, 'anti-ballete,' literally means 'to throw back and forth' or 'to exchange.' It paints a picture of active discussion, perhaps even debate or wrestling with ideas.
Grief's Grip
These disciples weren't just idly chatting; they were deeply immersed in their sorrow over Jesus' crucifixion. Their conversation was a desperate attempt to make sense of the devastating events. Their sadness was so palpable ('looking sad') that it was the most obvious thing about them.
Jesus' question isn't an accusation, but an invitation. He wants to understand their hearts and show them that their grief, while valid, doesn't have the final word.
Understand the original words
Hierosolyma · Greek Noun Proper
A distinct geographical location in Israel, functioning as the theological center of the Jewish nation, the site of the Temple, and the place of the crucifixion and resurrection. It represents God’s presence and the history of His covenantal dealings with His people.
paroikeō · Greek Noun
A person who brings news or messages; in a biblical context, it often refers to one who is temporarily residing in a place other than their home, or specifically a foreigner or stranger to local events.
This encounter happens on the very day of Jesus' resurrection, a day of profound shock, confusion, and dawning joy for His followers. The disciples' sadness and dashed hopes are palpable as they journey, highlighting the transformative power of encountering the risen Christ.
c. 30 AD
Jesus crucified and buried
Jesus of Nazareth, a prophet believed by his followers to be the redeemer of Israel, is arrested, tried, and crucified by Roman authorities. His body is placed in a tomb.
c. 30 AD
Women visit the tomb
On the morning of the third day after the crucifixion, women followers visit Jesus' tomb to find it empty and report seeing angels who claim Jesus is alive.
c. 30 AD— this verse
Disciples' journey to Emmaus
Two of Jesus' followers walk from Jerusalem to Emmaus, discussing the recent events and their dashed hopes. They are met by a stranger (the resurrected Jesus) who walks with them, unrecognized.
c. 30 AD
Jesus reveals Himself
Jesus breaks bread with the two disciples at Emmaus, revealing His identity in the process. The disciples then realize their encounter and return to Jerusalem to tell the others.
This passage shows a similar moment where Jesus appeared to Mary Magdalene, and she didn't recognize Him at first, indicating a pattern of His post-resurrection appearances where recognition wasn't immediate.
Genesis 32:24-30Jacob wrestled with God and was blessed but not recognized by name, illustrating how divine encounters can happen without immediate identification.
Acts 8:30-31Philip the evangelist encounters an Ethiopian eunuch reading Isaiah and asks him if he understands, mirroring Jesus' question to the disciples about their conversation and their sadness.
1 Corinthians 15:3-8This passage lists the appearances of Jesus after His resurrection, establishing the reality of His risen state, which is the very subject the disciples are sad about not understanding.
Luke 24:45Jesus later opens the disciples' minds to understand the Scriptures, directly connecting to the disciples' confusion and sorrow, and fulfilling the need for understanding that Jesus addresses.
vincentLuke 24:17: "And he said unto them, What manner of communications are these that ye have one to another, as ye walk, and are sad?"
Ye have (ἀντιβάλλετε)Lit., throw back and forth; exchange."Discussed a doubt and tossed it to and fro" (Tennyson).And are sad (σκυθρωποί)Only here and Matthew 6:16, on which see note. The best texts put the interrogation point after walk, add καὶ ἐστάθησαν, and render, and they stood still, looking sad. So Rev.
meyerLuke 24:17: "And he said unto them, What manner of communications are these that ye have one to another, as ye walk, and are sad?"
Luke 24:17-18 . What are these discourses that ye in turn throw out to one another as ye walk, and are of gloomy countenance? Instead of καὶ ὄντες σκυθρωποί , the address passes over into the finite verb, bringing out this characteristic more emphatically, Matthiae, § 632; Kühner, § 675. 4. After καί we are not to supply τί (Beza). The relative clause οὓς ἀντιβάλλ .…
The phrasing "What is this conversation that you are holding with each other" highlights not just the words they're exchanging, but the very act of them throwing ideas back and forth. Jesus is observing their shared, pained dialogue as they walk, noticing how their sorrow shapes the very substance of their interaction.
Two disciples are walking away from Jerusalem, deeply disheartened and confused after Jesus' crucifixion, their hopes for Israel's redemption dashed. As they discuss these events, a stranger joins them, and Jesus, appearing unrecognized, inquires about the source of their sorrowful conversation.
Two disciples are walking away from Jerusalem, deeply disheartened and confused after Jesus' crucifixion, their hopes for Israel's redemption dashed. As they discuss these events, a stranger joins them, and Jesus, appearing unrecognized, inquires about the source of their sorrowful conversation.
Get the original Greek and Hebrew, verse-by-verse context, and related passages inside the app.
Ask a follow-up
Ask Sola things like:
Live chat about Luke 24:17-18 is available in the Sola app.
c. 30 AD
Jesus appears to disciples in Jerusalem
Later that same day, Jesus appears to His disciples in Jerusalem, despite the doors being locked. He shows them His hands and side, affirming His resurrection.
"And he said to them, “What is this conversation that you are holding with each other as you walk?” And they stood still, looking sad. Then one of them, named Cleopas, answered him, “Are you the only visitor to Jerusalem who does not know t…" — The phrasing "What is this conversation that you are holding with each other" highlights not just the words they're exchanging, but the very act of them throwing ideas back and forth. Jesus is obse…
