Lamentations 4:3
Even jackals offer the breast; they nurse their young; but the daughter of my people has become cruel, like the ostriches in the wilderness.
English Standard Version (ESV)
This page isn't yet indexed by search engines.
The verse starkly contrasts the natural maternal instincts of even the wildest creatures with the unimaginable suffering of the women in Jerusalem. It's not just that the women are cruel; the text implies they are forced to appear so because the famine has left them with no milk and no food, a terrifying reversal of life's most basic provision.
The prophet is lamenting the devastating effects of the siege and famine in Jerusalem, describing the horrific conditions that have stripped away even basic maternal instincts. He contrasts the natural care shown by wild animals, like jackals, for their young with the unnatural cruelty the women of Jerusalem have been forced into, driven by desperation and starvation to neglect or even harm their own children. This stark comparison highlights the profound spiritual and physical collapse of the city and its people.
The world around us often surprises us with its instinctual devotion. Even the most unlikely creatures show a fierce protectiveness for their young.
The prophet paints a stark picture by comparing the cruelty of the people to the natural world. He uses vivid imagery: 'Even jackals offer the breast; they nurse their young.'
Scholars note that the Hebrew word 'tannin' can refer to various large, sometimes fearsome creatures, and while interpretations vary (sea monsters, dragons, even whales), the point is clear: even wild beasts, creatures without a clear understanding of God's law, act according to natural instinct to care for their offspring.
This isn't about praising animals, but about highlighting a profound deviation from the norm. These creatures, in their raw existence, demonstrate a basic maternal care that the people of Jerusalem have lost.
What happens when basic needs aren't met, and love itself seems to curdle into something harsh?
Ask a follow-up
Ask Sola things like:
Live chat about Lamentations 4:3 is available in the Sola app.
The most heartbreaking part of the verse is the contrast: '...but the daughter of my people has become cruel, like the ostriches in the wilderness.'
This cruelty wasn't a casual disregard. Commentators suggest it was a consequence of extreme famine and suffering during the siege of Jerusalem. The women had no milk for their babies, and the gnawing hunger was so intense that some were driven to horrific acts.
It's crucial to understand this isn't a picture of innate evil, but of compassion eroded by absolute desperation. The comparison to ostriches—who are described as leaving their eggs or being hardened against their young—speaks to a loss of expected maternal care, a survival instinct overriding even the deepest bonds, likely fueled by the impossible scarcity of food.
Understand the original words
am · Hebrew Noun
The people of Israel or the community of believers; a collective term for the covenant people of God.
akhzari · Hebrew Adjective
In Scripture, often used to depict someone devoid of compassion or covenantal loyalty, acting against the natural protective instincts instilled by God.
The brutal famine and societal collapse during the Babylonian siege of Jerusalem pushed mothers to unimaginable acts, starkly contrasting with natural maternal instincts seen even in wild animals. This highlights the depth of the city's suffering and God's judgment.
c. 597 BC
First Babylonian Deportation
Nebuchadnezzar of Babylon deports thousands of Jews, including King Jehoiachin and the prophet Ezekiel, to Babylon. This event marks the beginning of the Babylonian exile and significantly weakens Jerusalem.
c. 589-587 BC— this verse
Siege and Fall of Jerusalem
Nebuchadnezzar besieges Jerusalem. The city endures a brutal famine and immense suffering before its walls are breached and the First Temple is destroyed.
c. 586 BC
Second Babylonian Deportation
Following the fall of Jerusalem, a larger group of Judeans are exiled to Babylon, completing the devastation of the land and its people.
This passage describes the ostrich's seemingly neglectful behavior towards its eggs, directly paralleling the comparison made in Lamentations 4:3 and highlighting the unnatural cruelty of the people.
Jeremiah 14:6Here, jackals are also mentioned in a context of desolation and distress, similar to the imagery of the desolate wilderness in Lamentations 4:3 and the suffering described.
Lamentations 2:20This verse speaks of mothers being forced to eat their own children due to extreme famine, providing a stark and gruesome fulfillment of the cruelty hinted at in Lamentations 4:3.
Deuteronomy 28:57This passage in the blessings and curses section foreshadows the horrific desperation of extreme famine, where 'her after-birth, and the children she gave birth to' would be eaten, connecting to the theme of mothers' cruelty.
barnesLamentations 4:3: "Even the sea monsters draw out the breast, they give suck to their young ones: the daughter of my people is become cruel, like the ostriches in the wilderness."
Sea monsters - Rather, jackals. Their young ones - "Their" whelps. The term is applied only to the young of dogs, lions, and the like.
wesleyLamentations 4:3: "Even the sea monsters draw out the breast, they give suck to their young ones: the daughter of my people is become cruel, like the ostriches in the wilderness."
4:3 Cruel - The Jewish women are become cruel to their children, or forced to appear so, having through the famine no milk to give them, nor any thing to relieve them. Ostriches - Like ostriches that lay their eggs, and leave them in the sand.
The verse starkly contrasts the natural maternal instincts of even the wildest creatures with the unimaginable suffering of the women in Jerusalem. It's not just that the women are cruel; the text implies they are forced to appear so because the famine has left them with no milk and no food, a terrifying reversal of life's most basic provision.
The prophet is lamenting the devastating effects of the siege and famine in Jerusalem, describing the horrific conditions that have stripped away even basic maternal instincts. He contrasts the natural care shown by wild animals, like jackals, for their young with the unnatural cruelty the women of Jerusalem have been forced into, driven by desperation and starvation to neglect or even harm their own children. This stark comparison highlights the profound spiritual and physical collapse of the city and its people.
The prophet is lamenting the devastating effects of the siege and famine in Jerusalem, describing the horrific conditions that have stripped away even basic maternal instincts. He contrasts the natural care shown by wild animals, like jackals, for their young with the unnatural cruelty the women of Jerusalem have been forced into, driven by desperation and starvation to neglect or even harm their own children. This stark comparison highlights the profound spiritual and physical collapse of the city and its people.
"Even jackals offer the breast; they nurse their young; but the daughter of my people has become cruel, like the ostriches in the wilderness." — The verse starkly contrasts the natural maternal instincts of even the wildest creatures with the unimaginable suffering of the women in Jerusalem. It's not just that the women are cruel; the text im…
Get the original Greek and Hebrew, verse-by-verse context, and related passages inside the app.
