Judges 21:16-18
This page isn't yet indexed by search engines.
The elders' question reveals a crucial, often overlooked, tension: they were desperately trying to uphold a rash oath, even if it meant finding "wives" in morally compromised ways. This shows how deeply the idea of a sworn vow, once made, was binding, yet their proposed solution bypasses true marital union and hints at future ethical compromises.
Then the elders of the congregation said, “What shall we do for wives for those who are left, since the women are destroyed out of Benjamin?” And they said, “There must be an inheritance for the survivors of Benjamin, that a tribe not be blotted out from Israel. Yet we cannot give them wives from our daughters.” For the people of Israel had sworn, “Cursed be he who gives a wife to Benjamin.”
English Standard Version (ESV)
Following the near annihilation of the tribe of Benjamin due to their horrific crime at Gibeah, the Israelite elders are faced with a crisis: the tribe is on the brink of extinction with no women left to bear children. Having sworn not to give their own daughters to the remaining Benjamites, they now desperately seek a solution to ensure Benjamin’s survival.
An oath was sworn, a tribe was nearly wiped out, and now a desperate people face a seemingly impossible problem. What happens when vows lead to ruin?
The elders are in a bind because of a vow made in haste and anger: 'none of us shall give his daughter unto Benjamin to wife.' This vow, intended to uphold justice after the crime at Gibeah, has led to a catastrophic shortage of women in the tribe of Benjamin.
The Literal vs. The Moral
The elders grapple with how to provide wives for the remaining 600 Benjamites. Their initial solution involved a raid for women, which we saw in the previous chapter. Now, even that hasn't solved the problem entirely, leaving them with hundreds of men still without wives.
This situation highlights a dangerous tendency: focusing on the letter of a vow while ignoring its spirit and devastating consequences. The original vow was meant to be a righteous act of justice, but its rigid enforcement has led to the near-annihilation of a tribe and now threatens the very existence of Benjamin. It's a stark reminder that our commitments, even those made with good intentions, must be guided by wisdom, compassion, and a recognition of unintended outcomes.
The elders' dilemma isn't just about finding wives; it's about the flawed decision-making process that got them here. How do poor choices cascade into greater sin?
The passage reveals a deep-seated problem: the Israelites, even their leaders, are acting out of ignorance and rashness. They swore a 'ban' (a cherem) against the tribe of Benjamin, leading to a brutal war that nearly wiped them out. Now, faced with the consequence of having too few women, they are forced into increasingly desperate and cruel measures.
Ask a follow-up
The Cycle of Violence
This wasn't just a one-time mistake. The elders' question in this verse is a direct result of the previous actions, which themselves stemmed from an initial act of violence against a Levite's concubine and the subsequent tribal war.
The elders' current predicament isn't a sign of God's abandonment, but a clear demonstration of how sin and poor leadership create a downward spiral. They should have sought God's wisdom and forgiveness for their vengeful actions, rather than trying to solve the resulting problem with more flawed, human-driven schemes.
Understand the original words
zaqen · Hebrew Noun
A formal title for the leaders or senior officials of a community or nation, responsible for governing and making decisions on behalf of the people.
edah · Hebrew Noun
A large gathering or assembly of the people of Israel, often possessing a religious or political significance, especially when gathered before the Lord.
nachalah · Hebrew Noun
The portion, allotment, or heritage passed down, often referring to the land or tribal status God granted to the families of Israel.
machah · Hebrew Verb
To be erased, wiped out, or completely destroyed; used often in contexts of divine judgment or the removal of a name from existence.
arur · Hebrew Adjective/Participle
A solemn vow, oath, or imprecation sworn before God, invoking divine judgment or penalty if the commitment is broken.
This verse highlights the desperate measures the elders resort to, driven by a strict adherence to a rash oath and the desire to preserve the tribe of Benjamin, even if it means violating social norms and causing further distress.
Early 11th Century BC
The Crime at Gibeah
A concubine of a Levite is brutally raped and murdered by men of the tribe of Benjamin in Gibeah. This act sparks outrage throughout Israel.
Early 11th Century BC
Israelite Civil War
All the tribes of Israel gather and wage war against the tribe of Benjamin to punish them for the crime at Gibeah. Most of the Benjamite men are killed.
Early 11th Century BC
Vow Against Giving Daughters to Benjamin
After initial defeats, the Israelites realize Benjamin will be annihilated. They swear a solemn oath at Mizpeh not to give any of their daughters to the Benjamites as wives.
Early 11th Century BC
Raid on Jabesh-gilead
To provide wives for the surviving Benjamites, the Israelites attack the town of Jabesh-gilead, which did not participate in the oath, and slaughter its men, taking 400 virgins as wives for the Benjamites.
Early 11th Century BC— this verse
Consultation for Remaining Benjamites
The elders of Israel realize that 200 Benjamite men still need wives, as the 400 virgins from Jabesh-gilead were not enough. They must find another solution.
Early 11th Century BC
The Shiloh Festival Plan
The elders devise a plan to encourage the remaining Benjamites to hide and seize wives from the young women attending the annual festival at Shiloh.
This passage shows God's initial command to be fruitful and multiply after the flood, highlighting the importance of human continuation that the elders in Judges are struggling to maintain.
Leviticus 21:14The laws for the high priest's marriage emphasize purity and the importance of his wife being a virgin. While the context in Judges is drastically different, it touches upon the societal expectation and concern surrounding a suitable wife for a man, albeit under extreme duress.
Ruth 4:11-12This passage describes the community's blessing on Boaz and Ruth, praying that their union would make them like Rachel and Leah, who built up the house of Israel. It underscores the communal responsibility and divine desire for families to flourish, contrasting with the desperate measures in Judges.
1 Samuel 15:3Here, Saul is commanded to utterly destroy the Amalekites, a 'ban' or 'cherem.' This connects to the oath taken by the Israelites in Judges 21, showing the destructive potential of such vows when misunderstood or carried out with excessive zeal.
Nehemiah 13:25Nehemiah rebukes men for marrying foreign women, citing the sin of Solomon and emphasizing the purity of the Israelite line. This shows a long-standing concern for marriage within the community and the consequences of perceived transgression, echoing the elders' anxieties in Judges about providing suitable wives.
ellicottJudges 21:16: "Then the elders of the congregation said, How shall we do for wives for them that remain, seeing the women are destroyed out of Benjamin?"
(16) How shall we do . . .? — They want to keep their vow in the letter, while they break it in the spirit. The sense of the binding nature of the “ban” was intensely strong ( Exodus 20:7 ; Ezekiel 17:18-19 ), but, as is so often the case among rude and ignorant people, they fancied that it was sufficient to keep it literally, while in effect…
gillJudges 21:16: "Then the elders of the congregation said, How shall we do for wives for them that remain, seeing the women are destroyed out of Benjamin?"
Then the elders of the congregation said.... This being the case, that there were not wives enough for them, they were obliged to consult again, and consider of another expedient to provide for them; and this motion came from the elders of the people, not only in years, but in office: how shall we do for wives for them that remain: the other t…
The elders' question reveals a crucial, often overlooked, tension: they were desperately trying to uphold a rash oath, even if it meant finding "wives" in morally compromised ways. This shows how deeply the idea of a sworn vow, once made, was binding, yet their proposed solution bypasses true marital union and hints at future ethical compromises.
Following the near annihilation of the tribe of Benjamin due to their horrific crime at Gibeah, the Israelite elders are faced with a crisis: the tribe is on the brink of extinction with no women left to bear children. Having sworn not to give their own daughters to the remaining Benjamites, they now desperately seek a solution to ensure Benjamin’s survival.
Following the near annihilation of the tribe of Benjamin due to their horrific crime at Gibeah, the Israelite elders are faced with a crisis: the tribe is on the brink of extinction with no women left to bear children. Having sworn not to give their own daughters to the remaining Benjamites, they now desperately seek a solution to ensure Benjamin’s survival.
"Then the elders of the congregation said, “What shall we do for wives for those who are left, since the women are destroyed out of Benjamin?” And they said, “There must be an inheritance for the survivors of Benjamin, that a tribe not be b…" — The elders' question reveals a crucial, often overlooked, tension: they were desperately trying to uphold a rash oath, even if it meant finding "wives" in morally compromised ways. This shows how dee…
Get the original Greek and Hebrew, verse-by-verse context, and related passages inside the app.
Last reviewed October 2026
