John 9:2
And his disciples asked him, “Rabbi, who sinned, this man or his parents, that he was born blind?”
English Standard Version (ESV)
This page isn't yet indexed by search engines.
The disciples' question reveals a common, and often flawed, assumption: that suffering is always a direct punishment for sin, either the individual's or their parents'. They are so convinced of this link that they couldn't fathom blindness from birth unless it was a consequence of some specific sin, missing Jesus' broader perspective that suffering can also be for God's glory and purposes.
As Jesus passed by, He saw a man born blind, prompting His disciples to question the reason for such a profound affliction. They immediately connected suffering with sin, asking if the man or his parents were responsible, reflecting common Jewish beliefs about divine retribution. Jesus, however, was about to reveal a deeper purpose behind this man's condition, demonstrating God's power and glory.
When Jesus' followers saw a man born blind, their immediate thought wasn't 'How can we help?' but 'Whose fault is it?' What does this reveal about their understanding of suffering?
The disciples approached the man's blindness with a deeply ingrained belief: suffering equals sin. They presented two options – the man himself or his parents – assuming that this affliction must be a direct punishment.
This perspective, common among many Jews at the time, often linked misfortunes directly to specific sins. As commentators note, they wrestled with whether the sin was original to the man (perhaps even before birth, due to complex ideas about souls or fetal development) or inherited from his parents (a concept echoing the Old Testament's descriptions of generational consequences).
However, this common assumption oversimplified God's complex ways. It focused on assigning blame rather than understanding the deeper purposes behind suffering.
Jesus’ answer is startling! He dismisses their carefully constructed options and points to a completely different reason for the man’s condition. What was he trying to teach them?
Jesus cuts through the disciples' speculative question with a profound correction: 'Neither did this man sin, nor his parents.' He then reveals the true purpose: 'but that the works of God might be displayed in him.'
This wasn't to say that no one ever suffers for sin. Rather, Jesus redirects their focus from assigning blame to recognizing divine purpose. He shows that suffering isn't always a direct consequence of a specific sin, but can be an arena where God's power and glory are revealed.
This miracle becomes a platform for God’s magnificent work. The man’s blindness, which the disciples saw as a problem to be explained by sin, Jesus saw as an opportunity for God’s power to be gloriously demonstrated through healing.
Understand the original words
rhabbi · Hebrew/Greek Noun
A title of respect meaning "my great one" or "my master," used to address a teacher of the Jewish law. In the Gospels, it is frequently used to address Jesus, acknowledging His authority as a teacher.
hamartano · Greek Verb
Refers to missing the mark of God's holiness or transgressing His revealed will. Biblically, sin is an alienation from God that affects all of humanity and requires divine atonement.
The disciples' question reflects a common Jewish belief linking suffering directly to sin, a view Jesus challenges by pointing to a deeper purpose for this man's condition.
c. 20-30 AD— this verse
Jesus' Public Ministry in Galilee
Jesus is actively teaching and performing miracles in various towns and villages around the Sea of Galilee during his public ministry.
c. 30 AD
Jesus Enters Jerusalem for Passover
Jesus makes his final journey to Jerusalem for the Passover festival, a time of heightened religious and political tension.
c. 30 AD
Crucifixion and Resurrection of Jesus
Jesus is crucified and then resurrected, marking the central event of Christian faith.
c. 40-50 AD
Early Spread of Christianity
The Christian movement begins to spread beyond Jerusalem, with followers establishing communities in various regions.
c. 60s AD
This passage directly addresses the idea that the sins of parents can affect their children, a concept central to the disciples' question about the man born blind.
Job 1:1-12Job's story powerfully illustrates suffering that is not directly a punishment for personal sin, challenging the disciples' assumption that all affliction stems from sin, whether the individual's or their parents'.
Luke 13:1-5In this passage, Jesus confronts a similar assumption that sudden or tragic suffering (like the fall of the tower of Siloam or the death of Galileans) is always a direct consequence of sin, offering a parallel teaching to John 9:2.
Romans 5:12This verse explains how sin entered the world through one man and death through sin, establishing the universal reality of sin's consequences but not necessarily linking every individual's suffering to a specific sin.
Ecclesiastes 9:11This proverb highlights that not all misfortunes are directly tied to the individual's actions or specific sins, suggesting that 'time and chance' (or God's sovereign purposes) play a role in human events.
calvinJohn 9:1-5: "And as Jesus passed by, he saw a man which was blind from his birth."
- And Jesus, passing by, saw a man blind from his birth. 2. And his disciples asked him, saying, Rabbi, who hath sinned, this man, or his parents, that he was born blind? 3. Jesus answered, Neither did this man sin, nor his parents; but that the works of God may be displayed in him. 4. I must work the works of him who sent me, while it is day; the night cometh, when no man can work. 5. While I am in the world, I…
gillJohn 9:2: "And his disciples asked him, saying, Master, who did sin, this man, or his parents, that he was born blind?"
And his disciples asked him,.... It may be that some of the twelve apostles, or others of his disciples, might put the following question to him on sight of this blind man, who by some means or another knew was born blind: saying, master, who did man, or his parents, that he was born blind? the first of these questions, whether the man himself had sinned before he was born, wh…
The disciples' question reveals a common, and often flawed, assumption: that suffering is always a direct punishment for sin, either the individual's or their parents'. They are so convinced of this link that they couldn't fathom blindness from birth unless it was a consequence of some specific sin, missing Jesus' broader perspective that suffering can also be for God's glory and purposes.
As Jesus passed by, He saw a man born blind, prompting His disciples to question the reason for such a profound affliction. They immediately connected suffering with sin, asking if the man or his parents were responsible, reflecting common Jewish beliefs about divine retribution. Jesus, however, was about to reveal a deeper purpose behind this man's condition, demonstrating God's power and glory.
As Jesus passed by, He saw a man born blind, prompting His disciples to question the reason for such a profound affliction. They immediately connected suffering with sin, asking if the man or his parents were responsible, reflecting common Jewish beliefs about divine retribution. Jesus, however, was about to reveal a deeper purpose behind this man's condition, demonstrating God's power and glory.
Get the original Greek and Hebrew, verse-by-verse context, and related passages inside the app.
Ask a follow-up
Ask Sola things like:
Live chat about John 9:2 is available in the Sola app.
Composition of the Gospel of John
The Gospel of John, which records this event, is believed to have been written during this period, likely in Ephesus.
"And his disciples asked him, “Rabbi, who sinned, this man or his parents, that he was born blind?”" — The disciples' question reveals a common, and often flawed, assumption: that suffering is always a direct punishment for sin, either the individual's or their parents'. They are so convinced of thi…
