Job 31:16-17
“If I have withheld anything that the poor desired, or have caused the eyes of the widow to fail, or have eaten my morsel alone, and the fatherless has not eaten of it
English Standard Version (ESV)
This page isn't yet indexed by search engines.
Job isn't just saying he didn't refuse help; he's emphasizing he didn't make the desperate wait so long that their hope itself withered away. The "failing of the eyes" speaks to a deep discouragement, a soul-crushing disappointment when relief is not only denied but anticipated in vain. This reveals that compassion isn't just about the action, but the timing and the profound impact of dashed expectations on the vulnerable.
Job is in the midst of his solemn oath, a declaration of his innocence by calling down curses upon himself if he has lived unjustly. He's specifically addressing accusations that he neglected the poor and vulnerable, particularly widows and fatherless children, as brought up by his accusers. He maintains he was known for his generosity and compassion, not for denying help or causing hope to fade in those most in need.
Job isn't just talking about giving handouts; he's talking about responding to real needs. What does it mean to not 'withhold' what the poor desire?
Job declares his innocence regarding the poor. He wasn't someone who denied them what they genuinely needed or wished for.
Responding to Desire
The phrasing 'withheld the poor from their desire' means Job didn't ignore or refuse legitimate requests from those in need. It wasn't about fulfilling every whim, but about not obstructing or neglecting genuine needs when he had the means to help.
No Frustrated Hopes
Similarly, 'caused the eyes of the widow to fail' speaks to not disappointing her expectations. When a widow looked to him for help, justice, or charity, her hope wasn't met with prolonged, empty waiting. Her eyes wouldn't fail from looking in vain.
Job's challenge isn't just about actions, but about the intention behind them. He’s defending his heart's posture towards the vulnerable.
Ask a follow-up
Ask Sola things like:
Live chat about Job 31:16-17 is available in the Sola app.
Job's defense goes beyond mere actions; it touches on the motivation and the impact of his dealings with the vulnerable.
Promptness Over Delay
'Caused the eyes of the widow to fail' strongly implies a lack of delay. The 'failing of the eyes' is a vivid picture of prolonged, weary waiting, hoping for help that never comes. Job asserts he didn't subject widows to this kind of agonizing expectation.
Active Benevolence
He didn't just avoid actively harming the poor; he actively met their desires and brought relief. This wasn't about begrudgingly giving what was left over. It was about ensuring their needs were met promptly and with a willingness that didn't leave them feeling hopeless.
Understand the original words
dal · Hebrew Adjective
One who lacks material resources and is socially or economically disadvantaged. In Scripture, the poor are often the object of God's special concern and protection, and believers are commanded to care for them.
almanah · Hebrew Noun
A woman whose husband is deceased. Throughout the Bible, widows are categorized among the most vulnerable members of society, and God explicitly demands justice and provision for them.
yathom · Hebrew Noun
One who has lost one or both parents. The Bible frequently pairs the fatherless with the widow and the sojourner as a group vulnerable to exploitation, whom God commands His people to protect and sustain.
Job's defense highlights the ethical standards of his time, emphasizing that generosity and justice towards the vulnerable, especially widows, were paramount virtues expected of leaders and prosperous individuals.
c. 1400 BC - 1000 BC— this verse
Patriarchal Period in the Ancient Near East
The book of Job is set during a time when tribal elders and wealthy landowners often served as judges and providers for their communities. Social standing was tied to wealth and generosity, especially towards vulnerable groups like widows and orphans.
c. 1400 BC - 1000 BC
Ancient Near Eastern Legal and Ethical Codes
Societies like those in Mesopotamia and Canaan had established norms and expectations regarding the treatment of the poor, widows, and fatherless. Violations could lead to social disgrace and divine displeasure.
c. 1400 BC - 1000 BC
The Wisdom Tradition
Job's discourse reflects the wisdom literature of the ancient Near East, which emphasized practical morality, justice, and righteousness as pathways to prosperity and divine favor. Eliphaz's accusations represent a common theological viewpoint within this tradition.
This passage lays out the principle of not withholding from a needy brother, directly echoing Job's affirmation and highlighting the importance of generosity towards the poor in the Law of Moses.
Psalm 69:3This psalm expresses a similar sentiment of weariness and failing hope due to distress, mirroring the 'failing of the eyes' that Job denies causing to the widow.
Proverbs 15:25This proverb directly states that the Lord 'uproots the house of the proud but maintains the widow's boundary,' underscoring the divine protection of widows and the severe consequences for those who harm them.
Isaiah 1:17This prophetic call to action commands them to 'learn to do good; seek justice, correct oppression; bring justice to the fatherless, plead the widow's cause,' aligning with Job's defense of his righteous treatment of vulnerable people.
Luke 18:1-8Jesus tells the parable of the persistent widow, emphasizing God's eventual justice for the oppressed and the widow's persistent plea, which indirectly speaks to the grave sin of ignoring or frustrating such pleas.
bensonJob 31:16: "If I have withheld the poor from their desire, or have caused the eyes of the widow to fail;"
Job 31:16-17 . If I have withheld the poor, &c. — If I have denied them what they desired of me, either in justice or from necessity; for he was under no obligation to grant their vain or inordinate desires. Or have caused the eyes of the widow to fail — With tedious expectation of my justice or charity. I durst neither deny nor delay my help, when they needed or required it. Or have eaten…
wesleyJob 31:16: "If I have withheld the poor from their desire, or have caused the eyes of the widow to fail;"
31:16 If I - Denied them what they desired of me. To fail - With tedious expectation of my justice or charity. Job is most large upon this head, because in this matter Eliphaz had most particularly accused him.
Job isn't just saying he didn't refuse help; he's emphasizing he didn't make the desperate wait so long that their hope itself withered away. The "failing of the eyes" speaks to a deep discouragement, a soul-crushing disappointment when relief is not only denied but anticipated in vain. This reveals that compassion isn't just about the action, but the timing and the profound impact of dashed expectations on the vulnerable.
Job is in the midst of his solemn oath, a declaration of his innocence by calling down curses upon himself if he has lived unjustly. He's specifically addressing accusations that he neglected the poor and vulnerable, particularly widows and fatherless children, as brought up by his accusers. He maintains he was known for his generosity and compassion, not for denying help or causing hope to fade in those most in need.
Job is in the midst of his solemn oath, a declaration of his innocence by calling down curses upon himself if he has lived unjustly. He's specifically addressing accusations that he neglected the poor and vulnerable, particularly widows and fatherless children, as brought up by his accusers. He maintains he was known for his generosity and compassion, not for denying help or causing hope to fade in those most in need.
"“If I have withheld anything that the poor desired, or have caused the eyes of the widow to fail, or have eaten my morsel alone, and the fatherless has not eaten of it" — Job isn't just saying he didn't refuse help; he's emphasizing he didn't make the desperate wait so long that their hope itself withered away. The "failing of the eyes" speaks to a deep discourageme…
Get the original Greek and Hebrew, verse-by-verse context, and related passages inside the app.
