2 Samuel 16:10
This page isn't yet indexed by search engines.
When David says, "Who then shall say, 'Why have you done so?'" he's not just tolerating Shimei's insult; he's seeing it as God's direct decree. He’s acknowledging that even the most painful words and actions can be instruments in God's hand to discipline His people.
But the king said, “What have I to do with you, you sons of Zeruiah? If he is cursing because the LORD has said to him, ‘Curse David,’ who then shall say, ‘Why have you done so?’”
English Standard Version (ESV)
David is fleeing Jerusalem because his own son, Absalom, has launched a rebellion to take the throne. As David and his men make their desperate escape, a man named Shimei from the house of Saul starts hurling insults and stones at them, accusing David of many wrongdoings. David's loyal but hot-headed nephew, Abishai, is ready to strike Shimei down, but David stops him, choosing to endure this public humiliation, believing it might be God's doing.
Sometimes, the worst things happen. People we trust betray us, and enemies lash out. How do we make sense of it all?
In this intense moment, David is being cursed and insulted by Shimei. His own nephews, Joab and Abishai, are furious and want to silence Shimei immediately. But David stops them. He sees beyond Shimei's personal hatred and recognizes a potential divine hand at work.
A Deeper Perspective
David doesn't deny the pain or the injustice. Instead, he asks a profound question: 'If the LORD has told him to curse me...' This shows a deep, albeit painful, trust in God's ultimate control. Even when people act out of malice, David considers that God might be using their actions for a purpose.
This doesn't mean God causes evil or endorses sin. But it means He is sovereign over all events, including our suffering, and can even weave them into His larger plan.
When someone wrongs you deeply, the instinct is often to strike back. Why is that so dangerous, especially for leaders?
David's sons, Joab and Abishai, are ready to attack Shimei. Their motive is loyalty and protection of David, but their response is rooted in immediate, human anger.
Preserving the King's Integrity
David's refusal to retaliate is critical. He understands that acting on his own anger, or allowing his men to act on theirs, could escalate the situation and damage his own reputation and God's name. His restraint shows a higher wisdom.
Ask a follow-up
By stopping his men, David prevents a cycle of violence and maintains a posture of trust in God's justice, rather than taking matters into his own hands. This is a powerful example for anyone in a position of influence.
David's reflection in this moment, amidst his son's rebellion and a kinsman's vicious cursing, reveals his profound understanding that even the most painful personal attacks can be seen through the lens of God's sovereign will.
c. 1010 BC
David Anointed King
David, Jesse's youngest son, is secretly anointed king by Samuel, setting him on a path to kingship over Israel. This marks the beginning of his extraordinary, yet tumultuous, life.
c. 1005 BC
Saul Pursues David
King Saul, deeply jealous of David's popularity, relentlessly hunts David, forcing him into hiding in the wilderness. This period forged David's resilience and leadership skills under extreme pressure.
c. 1002 BC
David Spares Saul
Twice David has the opportunity to kill Saul but refuses, showing deep respect for God's anointed king. These encounters highlight David's character and his understanding of divine authority.
c. 999 BC
Death of Saul and Jonathan
Saul and his son Jonathan are killed in battle against the Philistines. David grieves profoundly, solidifying his claim to the throne of Israel.
c. 995 BC
David Becomes King of All Israel
After ruling over Judah for years, David is finally recognized as king over the entire united Israel, establishing his capital in Jerusalem.
c. 986 BC— this verse
Absalom's Rebellion
David's own son, Absalom, incites a widespread rebellion, forcing David to flee Jerusalem in disgrace. This is a devastating betrayal, bringing David's reign to a crisis point.
c. 985 BC
Shimei Curses David
As David flees Jerusalem during Absalom's rebellion, Shimei, a relative of Saul, curses and stones David. This is the moment David reflects on why he endures such insult.
Here, David echoes this sentiment when sparing Saul's life, demonstrating his understanding that God's hand is sovereign even in difficult circumstances and his own suffering.
Job 1:21This passage reflects a similar spirit of submission to God's sovereignty in the face of immense loss, acknowledging that the Lord gives and the Lord takes away.
Romans 8:28This New Testament passage reinforces David's perspective, assuring believers that God works all things for good for those who love Him, even when those things feel like a curse.
Lamentations 3:38This verse speaks to the ultimate source of both good and evil, aligning with David's recognition that even destructive words or actions ultimately come through God's permission or decree.
When David says, "Who then shall say, 'Why have you done so?'" he's not just tolerating Shimei's insult; he's seeing it as God's direct decree. He’s acknowledging that even the most painful words and actions can be instruments in God's hand to discipline His people.
David is fleeing Jerusalem because his own son, Absalom, has launched a rebellion to take the throne. As David and his men make their desperate escape, a man named Shimei from the house of Saul starts hurling insults and stones at them, accusing David of many wrongdoings. David's loyal but hot-headed nephew, Abishai, is ready to strike Shimei down, but David stops him, choosing to endure this public humiliation, believing it might be God's doing.
David is fleeing Jerusalem because his own son, Absalom, has launched a rebellion to take the throne. As David and his men make their desperate escape, a man named Shimei from the house of Saul starts hurling insults and stones at them, accusing David of many wrongdoings. David's loyal but hot-headed nephew, Abishai, is ready to strike Shimei down, but David stops him, choosing to endure this public humiliation, believing it might be God's doing.
"But the king said, “What have I to do with you, you sons of Zeruiah? If he is cursing because the LORD has said to him, ‘Curse David,’ who then shall say, ‘Why have you done so?’”" — When David says, "Who then shall say, 'Why have you done so?'" he's not just tolerating Shimei's insult; he's seeing it as God's direct decree. He’s acknowledging that even the most painful words and…
Get the original Greek and Hebrew, verse-by-verse context, and related passages inside the app.
Last reviewed October 2026
