But he said to her, “You speak as one of the foolish women would speak. Shall we receive good from God, and shall we not receive evil?” In all this Job did not sin with his lips.
English Standard Version (ESV)
Job's response to his wife is profound because he immediately frames suffering not as a deviation from God's goodness, but as an inseparable part of receiving from God's hand. He implies that a truly wise perspective accepts both the good and the bad as coming from the same divine source, without demanding an explanation or expecting only blessings.
But he said to her, “You speak as one of the foolish women would speak. Shall we receive good from God, and shall we not receive evil?” In all this Job did not sin with his lips.
English Standard Version (ESV)
Job's wife, witnessing his immense suffering, urges him to "curse God and die." In response, Job rebukes her, calling her words foolish and impious, and asserts that accepting good from God means one must also accept evil. Despite the agony of his physical torment and his wife's temptation to despair, Job's lips remain blameless.
When everything is falling apart, and doubt creeps in, how do we distinguish between a wise acceptance of God's will and a foolish, faithless reaction?
Job's wife, in her despair, suggests a radical and faithless approach: 'Curse God and die.' Job’s response immediately identifies this as 'foolishness.' But what kind of foolishness is it?
Not Just Ignorance, but Impatience
The word used for 'foolish' here isn't just about a lack of knowledge. It points to a deep-seated impiety, a rejection of God's rightful authority. It's the kind of 'foolishness' that leads to wickedness because it doesn't acknowledge God's ultimate control and goodness.
The Great Exchange
Job’s profound question, 'Shall we receive good from God, and shall we not receive evil?' gets to the heart of true faith. It’s not about a transactional relationship where we only expect blessings. It’s about recognizing that God, in His sovereignty, is the giver of all things – both comfort and calamity. To accept the good with joy, but to rail against the evil, reveals a flawed understanding of who God is and our place before Him. True faith accepts both, understanding that even in suffering, God is at work.
A Higher Perspective
Job’s statement reflects an understanding that life isn't just a series of pleasant experiences. Both good and evil, in their own way, can serve God’s purposes. The good blesses us and points us to Him; the evil, when rightly received, can refine us, teach us humility, and draw us closer to Him. This perspective is far from foolishness; it is a profound, albeit difficult, wisdom.
Ask a follow-up
We often think of sin as something we do or say. But what about the thoughts and attitudes that remain hidden within?
The verse concludes with a powerful affirmation: 'In all this Job did not sin with his lips.' This highlights the remarkable restraint Job exercised under immense pressure. His wife’s words were a direct temptation to curse God and abandon faith entirely.
Guarding the Mouth
Job's ability to respond with measured wisdom, rather than a bitter curse, is extraordinary. He refused to let the pain erupt into blasphemy or accusation against God. His lips remained silent regarding any sinful complaint, holding fast to a basic, yet profound, acknowledgment of God's sovereignty.
A Deeper Examination
However, some ancient interpretations suggest that while Job’s lips were sinless, his heart might have still been wrestling. This doesn’t diminish Job’s faithfulness but points to the intense internal battle. True integrity isn't just about what we outwardly express, but also about the internal posture of our hearts towards God, even when those hearts are struggling.
The True Test
This distinction between outward expression and inner thought reminds us that God sees more than our actions. He examines the heart. Job's story, even at this stage, shows a man striving to maintain outward godliness while inwardly grappling with unimaginable loss. His spoken words were pure, a testament to his deep-seated integrity.
Understand the original words
nebalah · Hebrew Adjective/Noun
In the Old Testament, the "fool" is not someone lacking intelligence, but one who lacks moral and spiritual wisdom, effectively living as if God does not exist or does not matter.
chata' · Hebrew Verb
To miss the mark of God's holy standard; it is an act of rebellion against God's law, character, or will, whether by thought, word, or deed.
This passage speaks of the 'wages of sin' as death, contrasting with the 'free gift of God' which is eternal life, echoing Job's acknowledgment that both good and 'evil' (which can be understood as hardship or suffering) are within God's domain.
Hebrews 12:7-11The author of Hebrews explains that God disciplines those He loves, not for pleasure, but for our good and to make us holy, which aligns with Job's mature acceptance that suffering, like prosperity, comes from God and has a purpose.
1 Peter 4:12-13Peter encourages believers not to be surprised by fiery trials, but to rejoice as they share in Christ's sufferings, which resonates with Job's perspective that enduring hardship from God is part of the faithful life, not a reason for disbelief.
Genesis 2:16-17The first command given to Adam establishes a direct link between obedience and life, and disobedience with death, highlighting the foundational principle that God's word governs both well-being and consequences, a concept Job touches upon when questioning the reception of 'evil'.
Ecclesiastes 7:14This verse advises to rejoice in good times and consider that God has made the day of adversity alongside the day of prosperity, directly supporting Job's argument to his wife that receiving good does not exclude the acceptance of evil from God's hand.
bensonJob 2:10: "But he said unto her, Thou speakest as one of the foolish women speaketh. What? shall we receive good at the hand of God, and shall we not receive evil? In all this did not Job sin with his lips."
Job 2:10 . But he said, Thou speakest as one of the foolish women speaketh — That is, like a rash, inconsiderate, and weak woman, that does not understand nor mind what she says: or rather, like a wicked and profane person, for such are frequently called fools in the Scriptures. Shall we re…
jfbJob 2:9-13: "Then said his wife unto him, Dost thou still retain thine integrity? curse God, and die."
Job 2:9-13. Job Reproves His Wife.9. curse God—rather, "renounce" God. (See on [493]Job 1:5) [Umbreit]. However, it was usual among the heathens, when disappointed in their prayers accompanied with offerings to their gods, to reproach and curse them.and die—that is, take thy farewell of God and so die. For no good is to be got out of religion, either here or hereafter; or, at least, not in thi…
Job's response to his wife is profound because he immediately frames suffering not as a deviation from God's goodness, but as an inseparable part of receiving from God's hand. He implies that a truly wise perspective accepts both the good and the bad as coming from the same divine source, without demanding an explanation or expecting only blessings.
Job's wife, witnessing his immense suffering, urges him to "curse God and die." In response, Job rebukes her, calling her words foolish and impious, and asserts that accepting good from God means one must also accept evil. Despite the agony of his physical torment and his wife's temptation to despair, Job's lips remain blameless.
Job's wife, witnessing his immense suffering, urges him to "curse God and die." In response, Job rebukes her, calling her words foolish and impious, and asserts that accepting good from God means one must also accept evil. Despite the agony of his physical torment and his wife's temptation to despair, Job's lips remain blameless.
"But he said to her, “You speak as one of the foolish women would speak. Shall we receive good from God, and shall we not receive evil?” In all this Job did not sin with his lips." — Job's response to his wife is profound because he immediately frames suffering not as a deviation from God's goodness, but as an inseparable part of receiving from God's hand. He implies that a truly…
Get the original Greek and Hebrew, verse-by-verse context, and related passages inside the app.
Last reviewed October 2026