Then I broke my second staff Union, annulling the brotherhood between Judah and Israel.
English Standard Version (ESV)
All verses
Zechariah 11:14
What does Zechariah 11:14 mean?
This page isn't yet indexed by search engines.
Zechariah 11:14
This page isn't yet indexed by search engines.
While the text might seem to point to a historical split between the kingdoms of Israel and Judah, it's actually foretelling a deeper, more tragic division: the ultimate rejection of the Messiah by the Jewish people, leading to the fracturing of their spiritual unity and their eventual scattering. This action signifies not just a political rupture, but a profound spiritual separation from God's favor because of their refusal of His appointed Shepherd.
Then I broke my second staff Union, annulling the brotherhood between Judah and Israel.
English Standard Version (ESV)
After the prophet symbolically "feeds" the flock with meager rations and breaks the staff called "Beauty," signifying the loss of the people's divine favor and privileges, he then breaks his second staff, "Bands." This action dramatically prefigures the complete dissolution of the unity and brotherhood between the tribes of Judah and the remaining Israelites, especially as they reject the Shepherd's care. This breaking foreshadows the tragic division, civil strife, and ultimate scattering of the nation that follows their rejection of God's leadership.
Zechariah's prophetic action involves not one, but two staffs. What did the second staff, named 'Bands,' represent, and why was it broken?
In Zechariah 11, the prophet acts out God's relationship with Israel. His first staff, 'Beauty,' symbolized the special privileges and covenant relationship God had with His people. When the people rejected this care, he broke it.
This verse describes the breaking of the second staff, called 'Bands.' This staff represented the unity and brotherhood that bound the tribes of Judah (the Southern Kingdom) and Israel (the Northern Kingdom) together. Even after the division of the kingdom, a semblance of brotherhood persisted, especially in shared worship and national identity.
By breaking the staff called 'Bands,' Zechariah powerfully declared that this vital bond was irrevocably severed. This symbolized the complete breakdown of fellowship, both religiously and politically, between the remaining parts of God's people.
God's judgment isn't arbitrary. When His people reject His care and guidance, what specific outcomes can they expect?
The breaking of the 'Bands' staff wasn't just a symbolic act; it was a foreshadowing of severe consequences for Israel and Judah. Their rejection of God's shepherdly care led directly to the dissolution of their national unity.
This breakdown manifested in several ways:
Ask a follow-up
Understand the original words
achavah · Hebrew Noun
An abstract concept signifying the covenantal bond, social harmony, or familial loyalty among the people of God, often requiring active maintenance through obedience to divine law.
Zechariah's prophecy of breaking the staff 'Bands' points to the complete dissolution of national unity, first fractured by exile and then utterly broken by the rejection of the Messiah and the subsequent destruction of Jerusalem.
c. 722 BC
Assyrian Exile of Northern Kingdom
The Assyrian Empire conquers the northern Kingdom of Israel, deporting many of its inhabitants and scattering the ten tribes. This event marks a significant division between the remaining southern Kingdom of Judah and the formerly united Israel.
586 BC
Babylonian Exile of Judah
The Neo-Babylonian Empire destroys Jerusalem and the Temple, exiling the population of the southern Kingdom of Judah. This event further exacerbates the division and sense of separation between the descendants of the original tribes.
c. 538 BC
Return from Exile
Following the Persian conquest of Babylon, Cyrus the Great allows the exiled Jews to return to Jerusalem. While many return, the unity of the original twelve tribes is not fully restored, and distinct identities and political relationships persist.
Early 1st century AD— this verse
Jesus' Ministry and Rejection
Jesus, the 'Good Shepherd,' arrives to minister to Judah and Israel. His rejection by the religious leaders and the majority of the people signifies a profound break, foreshadowing their ultimate scattering and loss of national unity.
AD 70
Destruction of Jerusalem
The Roman Empire destroys Jerusalem and its Temple in response to a Jewish revolt. This cataclysmic event shatters the remaining vestiges of national unity and scatters the Jewish people, fulfilling the prophecy of the broken staff 'Bands'.
This passage describes a symbolic act of joining two sticks together to represent the reunification of Judah and Israel into one nation, directly contrasting Zechariah's act of breaking them apart. It highlights the ideal of unity that was ultimately rejected by those who broke the staffs.
Matthew 23:37-38Jesus laments over Jerusalem, crying out that the city rejected Him, just as they had rejected God's messengers, leading to their destruction. This echoes Zechariah's prophecy of judgment and the breaking of bonds due to rejection of the Shepherd.
John 5:43Jesus tells the Jewish leaders that they would not receive Him, but would receive someone who came in his own name. This passage speaks to the rejection of the true Shepherd (Jesus) and the subsequent embrace of false leaders or ideologies, leading to division and ruin.
1 Samuel 15:23The prophet Samuel declares that rebellion against God's word is like the sin of idolatry and stubbornness. This connects to Zechariah's prophecy as the breaking of the staff 'Bands' signifies the severe consequences of Israel's stubborn rejection and rebellion against God's will.
Galatians 3:28This New Testament passage speaks of unity in Christ, where distinctions like Jew and Gentile are dissolved. It presents a powerful counterpoint to the broken brotherhood in Zechariah, showing the ultimate reconciliation God intends through Christ, which the Jews' rejection fractured.
bensonZechariah 11:14: "Then I cut asunder mine other staff, even Bands, that I might break the brotherhood between Judah and Israel."
Zechariah 11:14 . Then — As soon as I saw what little value they put upon me, and my pastoral care over them, and services for them; I cut asunder mine other staff, even Bands — The prophet did this in type, and Christ in reality; that I might break the brotherhood between Judah and Israel — That I might declare, or foreshow, that the friendship and union which had ex…
cambridgeZechariah 11:14: "Then I cut asunder mine other staff, even Bands, that I might break the brotherhood between Judah and Israel."
14 . I cut asunder mine other staff ] to signify both the completion of the rupture between the shepherd and the flock, with which he had now nothing more whatever to do, and also the second evil consequence of that rupture, which would befall the flock. Its beauty was gone already: its unity would now be gone also.
While the text might seem to point to a historical split between the kingdoms of Israel and Judah, it's actually foretelling a deeper, more tragic division: the ultimate rejection of the Messiah by the Jewish people, leading to the fracturing of their spiritual unity and their eventual scattering. This action signifies not just a political rupture, but a profound spiritual separation from God's favor because of their refusal of His appointed Shepherd.
After the prophet symbolically "feeds" the flock with meager rations and breaks the staff called "Beauty," signifying the loss of the people's divine favor and privileges, he then breaks his second staff, "Bands." This action dramatically prefigures the complete dissolution of the unity and brotherhood between the tribes of Judah and the remaining Israelites, especially as they reject the Shepherd's care. This breaking foreshadows the tragic division, civil strife, and ultimate scattering of the nation that follows their rejection of God's leadership.
After the prophet symbolically "feeds" the flock with meager rations and breaks the staff called "Beauty," signifying the loss of the people's divine favor and privileges, he then breaks his second staff, "Bands." This action dramatically prefigures the complete dissolution of the unity and brotherhood between the tribes of Judah and the remaining Israelites, especially as they reject the Shepherd's care. This breaking foreshadows the tragic division, civil strife, and ultimate scattering of the nation that follows their rejection of God's leadership.
"Then I broke my second staff Union, annulling the brotherhood between Judah and Israel." — While the text might seem to point to a historical split between the kingdoms of Israel and Judah, it's actually foretelling a deeper, more tragic division: the ultimate rejection of the Messiah by t…
Get the original Greek and Hebrew, verse-by-verse context, and related passages inside the app.
Last reviewed October 2026