What does it mean to 'test' God, especially after experiencing His power firsthand? It's more than just doubt; it's a deliberate challenge.
The phrase 'these ten times' isn't meant to be a precise mathematical count, though some traditions tried to list them. Instead, it signifies repeatedly, a pattern of behavior that had reached its full, exasperating limit. To 'test' or 'tempt' God, in this context, means to challenge His promises, His power, or His faithfulness. It's like saying, 'I don't really believe You can do what You said,' or 'I don't trust that You will provide.'
After seeing His glory and miracles, their continued testing shows a deep-seated rebellion. They weren't just forgetful; they were actively disobeying His voice— His commands and His spoken will, especially the command to go forward and possess the land.