Matthew 22:17
Tell us, then, what you think. Is it lawful to pay taxes to Caesar, or not?”
English Standard Version (ESV)
This page isn't yet indexed by search engines.
This isn't just a political question about taxes; it's a spiritual trap. They're asking if it's "lawful," or right according to God's law, to pay tribute to a foreign ruler, framing it as a choice between loyalty to Caesar and loyalty to God. This forces Jesus into a corner: affirm Caesar and appear unpatriotic, or deny Caesar and risk being accused of sedition.
Facing Jesus, a group of Pharisees and their allies, the Herodians, try to trap him with a question about paying taxes to the Roman emperor. If Jesus says yes, he risks alienating the Jewish people who resented Roman rule; if he says no, he could be accused of sedition. This sets the stage for Jesus to expose their hypocrisy and reveal a deeper truth about divided loyalties.
Imagine being caught between a political rock and a religious hard place. That's exactly where religious leaders tried to trap Jesus!
The Pharisees and Herodians, despite their differences, allied to corner Jesus with a seemingly impossible question. They wanted to force Jesus into a corner:
This wasn't a genuine search for truth; it was a calculated plot to discredit and potentially eliminate Jesus. They masked their malice with flattery, calling Him 'Teacher' and praising His supposed impartiality, but Jesus saw right through their hypocrisy.
Jesus didn't just answer a question; He flipped the whole perspective. What did He see that His questioners missed?
Jesus, seeing their wicked intentions, cleverly turned their own question back on them. He asked for a coin used for taxes.
When they produced a Roman denarius, Jesus pointed out the obvious: this coin bore Caesar's image and inscription. This was the key!
His response, 'Render to Caesar the things that are Caesar's, and to God the things that are God's,' wasn't a simple 'yes' or 'no.' It was a profound theological statement that established a framework for civic duty and divine allegiance, separating them while affirming God's ultimate claim.
Understand the original words
kēnsos · Greek Noun
A formal tribute, levy, or tax imposed by a governing authority upon subjects. In a Roman context, it represented submission to the empire.
c. 6 BC - 4 BC
Death of Herod the Great
The death of Herod the Great, a Roman client king, led to a division of his kingdom among his sons, creating political instability and increased Roman involvement in Judea.
AD 6
Ousting of Herod Archelaus
Judea, including Jerusalem, was placed under direct Roman prefects (like Pontius Pilate) after the deposition of Herod Archelaus, intensifying Roman taxation and governance.
c. AD 20s
Rise of Tax Resistance
Groups like the Zealots, inspired by figures like Judas of Galilee, began to actively resist Roman taxation, viewing it as a violation of God's sovereignty. This created a volatile religious and political climate.
c. AD 30-33— this verse
Jesus' Ministry in Judea
During Jesus' public ministry, Judea was under Roman rule, with Tiberius Caesar as emperor. The question of paying taxes to Caesar was a potent political and religious issue for Jewish people.
This passage directly echoes Jesus's teaching by stating, 'Pay to all what is due to them: taxes to whom taxes are due, revenue to whom revenue is due...' showing the consistent principle of honoring civil authority while also pointing to a higher allegiance.
Acts 5:29Peter's bold declaration, 'We must obey God rather than men,' provides a crucial counterpoint to the 'render to Caesar' principle, highlighting the ultimate authority of God when civil demands conflict with divine commands.
1 Peter 2:13-17This passage instructs believers to 'be subject for the Lord's sake to every human institution,' whether it be to the emperor as supreme, directly addressing the theme of submitting to governing authorities, even pagan ones, for the sake of righteousness.
Luke 23:2This verse shows the direct consequence the Pharisees hoped for: accusing Jesus of treason against Rome ('We found this man inciting our nation to refuse to pay taxes to the emperor'). This highlights the dangerous political trap Jesus was skillfully navigating.
ellicottMatthew 22:17: "Tell us therefore, What thinkest thou? Is it lawful to give tribute unto Caesar, or not?"
(17) Is it lawful to give tribute . . .? —The question was obviously framed as a dilemma. If answered in the affirmative, the Pharisees would be able to denounce Him to the people as a traitor to His country, courting the favour of their heathen oppressors. If in the negative, the Herodians (on the assumption which seems the more probable) could accuse Him, as He was eventually accused, of…
henryMatthew 22:15-22: "Then went the Pharisees, and took counsel how they might entangle him in his talk."
22:15-22 The Pharisees sent their disciples with the Herodians, a party among the Jews, who were for full subjection to the Roman emperor. Though opposed to each other, they joined against Christ. What they said of Christ was right; whether they knew it or not, blessed be God we know it. Jesus Christ was a faithful Teacher, and a bold reprover. Christ saw their wickedness. Whatever mask the hy…
This isn't just a political question about taxes; it's a spiritual trap. They're asking if it's "lawful," or right according to God's law, to pay tribute to a foreign ruler, framing it as a choice between loyalty to Caesar and loyalty to God. This forces Jesus into a corner: affirm Caesar and appear unpatriotic, or deny Caesar and risk being accused of sedition.
Facing Jesus, a group of Pharisees and their allies, the Herodians, try to trap him with a question about paying taxes to the Roman emperor. If Jesus says yes, he risks alienating the Jewish people who resented Roman rule; if he says no, he could be accused of sedition. This sets the stage for Jesus to expose their hypocrisy and reveal a deeper truth about divided loyalties.
Facing Jesus, a group of Pharisees and their allies, the Herodians, try to trap him with a question about paying taxes to the Roman emperor. If Jesus says yes, he risks alienating the Jewish people who resented Roman rule; if he says no, he could be accused of sedition. This sets the stage for Jesus to expose their hypocrisy and reveal a deeper truth about divided loyalties.
Get the original Greek and Hebrew, verse-by-verse context, and related passages inside the app.
Ask a follow-up
Ask Sola things like:
Live chat about Matthew 22:17 is available in the Sola app.
"Tell us, then, what you think. Is it lawful to pay taxes to Caesar, or not?”" — This isn't just a political question about taxes; it's a spiritual trap. They're asking if it's "lawful," or right according to God's law, to pay tribute to a foreign ruler, framing it as a choice…
