Malachi 1:3
but Esau I have hated. I have laid waste his hill country and left his heritage to jackals of the desert.”
English Standard Version (ESV)
This page isn't yet indexed by search engines.
While the verse speaks of "hating" Esau, the real insight lies in how God immediately demonstrates this "hatred" through a permanent, desolate destruction of his land, a fate Israel, despite their own punishment, was ultimately spared. This isn't about God's personal feelings, but about His sovereign judgment and the stark, enduring consequences for a people He chose to discipline differently.
Malachi begins by proclaiming God's deep love for His people Israel, but the people question this love, prompting God to compare their history with that of their sibling nation, Edom (descended from Esau). God declares He "hated" Esau, meaning He loved him less and chose Jacob instead, and highlights this by describing the desolation of Edom's mountainous homeland, a stark contrast to Israel's eventual restoration.
The word "hated" in reference to Esau sounds harsh, even unfair. How can a loving God "hate" someone?
This verse uses the strong word "hated" (Hebrew: 'sane'). It's crucial to understand this isn't about God's emotional revulsion like human hatred. Instead, it speaks to a divine, sovereign decision: God "loved" Jacob and comparatively "did not love" Esau.
A Choice, Not a Condemnation
Think of it like choosing between two equally good options, but you can only pick one. God's choice here wasn't based on Esau's actions (or foreseen actions), but on His own divine purpose. This theme of God's sovereign election is explored extensively in Romans 9, where Paul uses the Jacob and Esau story to show that God's plan stands not by human effort, but by His call.
Temporal, Not Eternal
Crucially, the context here focuses on the nations descended from Jacob (Israel) and Esau (Edom) and their earthly destinies. It's not a statement about the eternal salvation or damnation of individuals. God's love for Jacob meant blessings for his lineage, while His comparative lack of love for Esau meant desolation for his.
God's word often links sin with its consequences. Here, the desolation of Esau's land is presented as a sign of God's judgment.
Malachi isn't just stating an abstract theological point; he's describing a real-world outcome. The land of Edom, the mountainous region of Seir, was to become a wasteland, inhabited by wild animals ('jackals' or 'dragons').
A Fulfillment of Prophecy
This wasn't a new declaration but a confirmation of earlier prophetic warnings, like those from Jeremiah. While Jacob's people, Israel, faced exile, they were eventually restored. Edom, however, faced a more permanent desolation, a stark sign of God's lasting displeasure with their actions and their refusal to repent.
A Contrast in Destinies
The contrast is stark: Israel's land was eventually rebuilt and re-inhabited; Edom's was left to wild creatures. This outcome wasn't arbitrary but a consequence of Edom's persistent opposition to God's people and their own wickedness, leading to God's "indignation for ever," as further described in Malachi 1:4.
Understand the original words
sane' · Hebrew Verb
In a biblical context, this indicates divine rejection, judicial withdrawal of covenantal favor, or the setting aside of a person or group in favor of another for redemptive purposes.
Malachi's words highlight a stark contrast: while Israel faced hardship and exile, they were ultimately restored. The Edomites, however, suffered a more permanent devastation, illustrating God's differential treatment based on His sovereign choice and historical dealings with His people.
c. 7th century BC
Nebuchadnezzar's Campaigns
Nebuchadnezzar II of Babylon led military campaigns through the region, including against Edom, as foretold by prophets like Jeremiah and Ezekiel.
586 BC
Fall of Jerusalem
The Babylonians destroyed Jerusalem and the First Temple, initiating the Judean exile and significantly impacting the surrounding nations.
c. 581 BC— this verse
Edom's Desolation
Following the fall of Jerusalem, Nebuchadnezzar's forces likely subdued and devastated the Edomite territory, fulfilling prophecies of their destruction.
c. 538 BC
Return from Exile
Cyrus the Great allowed the Judean exiles to return to their homeland and rebuild Jerusalem and the Temple.
This passage directly precedes Malachi and explains the divine decree given to Rebekah, 'Two nations are in your womb, and two peoples shall be separated from your body. And one people shall be stronger than the other, and the older shall serve the younger.' This establishes the foundational difference in God's dealings with Jacob and Esau's descendants.
Romans 9:13The Apostle Paul quotes Malachi 1:3 directly, using it as a prime example to illustrate God's sovereign choice and election. This shows how the concept of God 'hating' Esau was understood in the New Testament context as part of God's overarching plan, not necessarily a statement about individual eternal destiny but about national or preferential dealings.
Obadiah 1:10-14The prophecy against Edom in Obadiah is a stark parallel to Malachi's statement. It details Edom's violence against their brother Jacob (Israel) and prophesies their complete destruction and desolation, aligning with the 'hated' and 'laid waste' imagery in Malachi.
Jeremiah 49:7-18Jeremiah prophesied the desolation of Edom, stating that wisdom would perish from Teman and that they would be overcome and scattered. This foretells the same fate of ruin and displacement described in Malachi, underscoring the long-standing judgment against Esau's descendants.
wesleyMalachi 1:3: "And I hated Esau, and laid his mountains and his heritage waste for the dragons of the wilderness."
1:3 I hated - I loved not Esau's posterity as I loved Jacob's. His heritage - Mount Seir with the neighbouring mountains. Waste - By Nebuchadnezzar's arms five years after the sacking of Jerusalem, and whereas Jacob's captivity returned, and their cities were rebuilt, Esau's never were. The dragons - Creatures which delight in desolate places, by which the utter desolation of Esau i…
clarkeMalachi 1:3: "And I hated Esau, and laid his mountains and his heritage waste for the dragons of the wilderness."
And I hated Esau - I have shown him less love; Genesis 29:30 , Genesis 29:31 . I comparatively hated him by giving him an inferior lot. And now, I have not only laid waste the dwelling-place of the Edomites, by the incursions of their enemies; but ( Malachi 1:4 ) they shall remain the perpetual monuments of my vengeance. On the subject of loving Jacob and hating Esau, see the notes…
While the verse speaks of "hating" Esau, the real insight lies in how God immediately demonstrates this "hatred" through a permanent, desolate destruction of his land, a fate Israel, despite their own punishment, was ultimately spared. This isn't about God's personal feelings, but about His sovereign judgment and the stark, enduring consequences for a people He chose to discipline differently.
Malachi begins by proclaiming God's deep love for His people Israel, but the people question this love, prompting God to compare their history with that of their sibling nation, Edom (descended from Esau). God declares He "hated" Esau, meaning He loved him less and chose Jacob instead, and highlights this by describing the desolation of Edom's mountainous homeland, a stark contrast to Israel's eventual restoration.
Malachi begins by proclaiming God's deep love for His people Israel, but the people question this love, prompting God to compare their history with that of their sibling nation, Edom (descended from Esau). God declares He "hated" Esau, meaning He loved him less and chose Jacob instead, and highlights this by describing the desolation of Edom's mountainous homeland, a stark contrast to Israel's eventual restoration.
Get the original Greek and Hebrew, verse-by-verse context, and related passages inside the app.
Ask a follow-up
Ask Sola things like:
Live chat about Malachi 1:3 is available in the Sola app.
Post-Exilic Period
Edom's Failure to Rebuild
Unlike the Jews who were eventually restored to their land, the Edomites did not recover from their desolation and were permanently displaced.
This passage records God's command to the Israelites not to provoke the Edomites or take their land, stating 'for I will not give you of their land a foot's breadth, because Mount Seir has been given to Esau as a possession.' Malachi's declaration that Esau's heritage was 'laid waste' powerfully contrasts with this earlier grant of possession, highlighting a dramatic reversal.
"but Esau I have hated. I have laid waste his hill country and left his heritage to jackals of the desert.”" — While the verse speaks of "hating" Esau, the real insight lies in how God immediately demonstrates this "hatred" through a permanent, desolate destruction of his land, a fate Israel, despite their ow…
