while others, to test him, kept seeking from him a sign from heaven.
English Standard Version (ESV)
These questioners weren't simply curious; they were actively trying to trap Jesus, hoping His response would prove they were right to suspect His power was not from God. They sought a sign from heaven not for genuine belief, but to find fault and justify their disbelief.
while others, to test him, kept seeking from him a sign from heaven.
English Standard Version (ESV)
Just before this, Jesus had cast out a demon, and the crowd was amazed but also divided, with some questioning the source of his power. Now, some of the crowd, influenced by skeptical religious leaders, press Jesus further, not out of genuine curiosity but to trap him, demanding a spectacular miracle from the sky as proof of his divine authority. This demand for a sign directly follows the account of Jesus' exorcism, highlighting the persistent unbelief and desire to test him that he faced.
Why would people ask Jesus for a sign and still not believe? It wasn't a genuine search for truth, but a trap.
When Jesus' opponents demanded a "sign from heaven," they weren't asking out of honest curiosity. They were 'tempting' him, a word that means to put someone to the test in a hostile way, looking for a reason to dismiss him.
Think of it like someone wanting to prove their friend is lying. Instead of listening to explanations, they say, 'Prove it! Show me something impossible!' Their goal isn't to be convinced, but to find a flaw or an excuse to disbelieve.
These questioners likely remembered stories of God sending signs like fire from heaven or pillars of cloud. They wanted Jesus to perform an undeniable, spectacular miracle to prove his divine authority – not to embrace it, but to scrutinize it and find fault.
Jesus' miracles weren't meant to force people to believe, but to open their eyes to the truth. Why did He refuse their demand for a sign?
The Bible commentators point out a crucial difference: these people wanted a sign to enforce acceptance, not to foster conviction. They wanted a spectacle, a public display that would either validate their suspicions or force them to acknowledge Jesus, giving them grounds for further accusation.
Jesus understood this. He knew that true faith isn't born from being coerced by overwhelming power, but from a willing heart responding to truth. Granting their demand would have been like giving a weapon to His enemies, allowing them to twist His power for their own agenda.
Ask a follow-up
He didn't perform miracles to impress or to end arguments. His mighty acts were demonstrations of God's kingdom breaking into the world, intended to draw people to Himself through genuine belief, not through compulsion.
Understand the original words
sēmeion · Greek Noun
A miraculous event or prophetic confirmation intended to authenticate a message or messenger from God. In the New Testament, it often refers to evidence of Jesus' messianic authority.
The demand for a sign from heaven wasn't just a neutral request; it echoed the very temptations Jesus faced in the wilderness, challenging Him to prove Himself in a way He had already refused. It revealed the deep-seated skepticism and hostility of His opponents.
c. 27-30 AD— this verse
Jesus' Public Ministry and Miracles
During Jesus' teaching and healing ministry, he performed numerous miracles, drawing large crowds and attracting the attention of religious leaders.
c. 28 AD
Jesus' Temptation in the Wilderness
Earlier in his ministry, Jesus was tempted by Satan to perform a sign from heaven to prove his divine identity and power. Jesus refused, prioritizing obedience to God over self-demonstration.
c. 29 AD
Pharisaical Opposition Intensifies
As Jesus' popularity grew, the religious elite, particularly the Pharisees, became increasingly hostile, seeking to discredit him and his ministry. They often challenged his authority and methods.
c. 30 AD
Jesus Rebukes the Pharisees
Jesus directly confronts the hypocrisy and spiritual blindness of the religious leaders, warning them of coming judgment.
This passage presents the same demand for a sign from Jesus, highlighting the persistent unbelief and testing nature of the religious leaders.
John 6:30Here, the crowds echo the same desire for a sign, asking Jesus what 'sign' He would perform to prove His authority, revealing a common pattern of seeking proof rather than believing.
1 Corinthians 1:22This verse speaks directly to the 'Jews' (referring to the Jewish people and their leaders) seeking 'signs,' contrasting it with the 'Greeks' seeking wisdom, underscoring the specific mindset that prompted such demands.
Exodus 13:21-22The 'sign from heaven' desired by the questioners likely alludes to dramatic, visible divine interventions like the pillar of cloud and fire that led Israel, showing the magnitude of what they were demanding.
Luke 4:3This reference shows Jesus facing a similar temptation in the wilderness to turn stones into bread, revealing the underlying theme of testing Jesus' divine authority and willingness to perform arbitrary acts of power.
vincentLuke 11:16: "And others, tempting him, sought of him a sign from heaven."
TemptingSee on temptation, Matthew 6:13.SignSee on Matthew 11:20.
pulpitLuke 11:16: "And others, tempting him, sought of him a sign from heaven."
Verse 16. - And others, tempting him, sought of him a sign from heaven. As in the case of Manoah or Elijah. Some such sign as the pillar of fire these cavilling Jews probably referred to. No doubt, in the course of the public teaching, in the presence of his mighty acts, Jesus was asked for such a sign on several occasions. His questioners would argue after this fashion: "We suspect that these great works of yours, especi…
These questioners weren't simply curious; they were actively trying to trap Jesus, hoping His response would prove they were right to suspect His power was not from God. They sought a sign from heaven not for genuine belief, but to find fault and justify their disbelief.
Just before this, Jesus had cast out a demon, and the crowd was amazed but also divided, with some questioning the source of his power. Now, some of the crowd, influenced by skeptical religious leaders, press Jesus further, not out of genuine curiosity but to trap him, demanding a spectacular miracle from the sky as proof of his divine authority. This demand for a sign directly follows the account of Jesus' exorcism, highlighting the persistent unbelief and desire to test him that he faced.
Just before this, Jesus had cast out a demon, and the crowd was amazed but also divided, with some questioning the source of his power. Now, some of the crowd, influenced by skeptical religious leaders, press Jesus further, not out of genuine curiosity but to trap him, demanding a spectacular miracle from the sky as proof of his divine authority. This demand for a sign directly follows the account of Jesus' exorcism, highlighting the persistent unbelief and desire to test him that he faced.
"while others, to test him, kept seeking from him a sign from heaven." — These questioners weren't simply curious; they were actively trying to trap Jesus, hoping His response would prove they were right to suspect His power was not from God. They sought a sign from heave…
Get the original Greek and Hebrew, verse-by-verse context, and related passages inside the app.
Last reviewed October 2026