John 8:17
In your Law it is written that the testimony of two people is true.
English Standard Version (ESV)
John 8:17
In your Law it is written that the testimony of two people is true.
English Standard Version (ESV)
This page isn't yet indexed by search engines.
Jesus here isn't just quoting a legal principle; he's subtly highlighting that their "law" is being interpreted by people who are judging with human limitations ("according to the flesh"). He's pointing out that their own legal framework, which requires two witnesses to establish truth, is about to be fulfilled by two divine witnesses—Himself and the Father—thus exposing their narrow, earthly judgment as insufficient.
{ "studyTitle": "Two Witnesses: Divine Testimony in the Temple", "timeMinutes": 8, "concepts": [ { "title": "A Divine Legal Argument", "hook": "Jesus is in a heated debate with religious leaders. How does he use their own legal system against them?", "teaching": "Jesus is in the temple, teaching and being challenged by religious leaders. They are judging him based on their human understanding and traditions, what the scholars call 'judging according to the flesh.' This means they're focused on outward appearances and their own limited perspectives, rather than spiritual truth.\n\nJesus counters this by appealing to their own Law. He quotes Deuteronomy 19:15, which states that the testimony of two witnesses is considered true. This was a fundamental principle in their legal system to ensure fairness and prevent false accusations.\n\nJesus is setting up a profound argument: If their Law says two human witnesses are enough to establish truth, then surely the testimony of two divine witnesses—himself and the Father—should be more than sufficient to establish Jesus' identity and mission. He's essentially saying, 'You have a standard for truth, and I'm meeting it with witnesses far greater than any human ones.'", "readItAgain": "Notice how Jesus says, 'In your Law it is written that the testimony of two people is true.' He's directly referencing their own legal code.", "reflectionPrompt": "When you feel misunderstood or wrongly judged, how can you bring 'divine witnesses' like Scripture or prayer into your situation, rather than just relying on your own defense?", "supportingReferences": [ { "reference": "Deuteronomy 19:15", "connection": "This is the Old Testament passage Jesus is referencing, establishing the principle of two witnesses for legal matters." }, { "reference": "1 John 5:9", "connection": "This New Testament passage echoes the idea of God's testimony being greater than human testimony." } ] }, { "title": "Beyond Human Judgment", "hook": "The religious leaders are judging Jesus by their standards. But Jesus' judgment operates on a completely different level.", "teaching": "The religious leaders were focused on the 'flesh' – their own limited understanding, human traditions, and outward appearances. They couldn't comprehend Jesus' divine origin or mission. Jesus points this out, saying, 'You judge according to the flesh.'\n\nJesus, however, does not judge this way. While he could judge them, he states, 'I judge no one.' This isn't to say he is without judgment, but that his judgment isn't based on flawed human standards. As one scholar put it, he 'abstains from performing the office of a judge' at that moment, choosing instead to reveal truth.\n\nHe clarifies that 'if I do judge, my judgment is true, for I am not alone, but I and the Father who sent me.' This means his judgment is grounded in divine truth and is validated by the Father. His actions and teachings carry an authority that transcends human opinion or legalistic interpretation.", "readItAgain": "Consider Jesus' words: 'You judge according to the flesh; I judge no one. Yet if I do judge, my judgment is true, for I am not alone, but I and the Father who sent me.'", "reflectionPrompt": "How might our own 'judging according to the flesh' prevent us from recognizing God's truth or His work in others?", "supportingReferences": [ { "reference": "John 3:17", "connection": "This verse reinforces that Jesus came not to condemn but to save, highlighting his non-judgmental approach in his initial mission." }, { "reference": "1 Corinthians 2:14", "connection": "This verse contrasts the 'natural person' (thinking like those judging by the flesh) with spiritual understanding." } ] } ] }
Ask a follow-up
Ask Sola things like:
Live chat about John 8:17 is available in the Sola app.
Jesus confronts religious leaders who claim to uphold the Law, but are actually judging wrongly. How does Jesus use 'your law' to expose their flawed judgment?
Jesus points to a principle in the Mosaic Law: the testimony of two witnesses is considered reliable and true (Deuteronomy 19:15). He uses this to highlight the hypocrisy of the religious leaders.
Judging by Appearance
They were judging Jesus based on outward appearances and their own traditions – 'judging according to the flesh,' as Calvin puts it. This means they were relying on human opinion, personal bias, and what seemed right to them, rather than on divine truth.
The True Law
Jesus, however, appeals to a higher standard. While they claim to know and follow 'the Law,' their actions prove otherwise. Jesus implies that their interpretation and application of the Law are flawed because they lack the divine perspective. He contrasts their fleshly judgment with his own 'true' judgment, which is grounded in his divine authority and unity with the Father.
Jesus immediately follows the mention of two witnesses with a profound claim about himself and the Father. What makes this testimony so powerful?
Jesus doesn't just cite the Law to win an argument; he uses it as a foundation to reveal his divine identity. He points out that while the Law requires two human witnesses for a testimony to be true, he has something far greater.
The Father's Testimony
Jesus states, 'I am one who testifies of myself, and the Father who sent me testifies of me' (John 8:18, context). He is one divine witness, and the Father is the second divine witness. This is a radical claim! He's essentially saying that his testimony is not just true by human standards, but by divine standards, which are infinitely higher.
Beyond Human Law
The religious leaders might have accepted the testimony of two men, but they rejected the testimony of God the Father and His Son. Jesus is making it clear that his judgment, and by extension his identity, is validated not by their flawed human assessment, but by the ultimate divine authority.
Understand the original words
martyria · Greek Noun
In a legal or religious context, this refers to a declaration of fact or truth, often used as evidence in a court or to confirm the validity of a claim. It carries the weight of authoritative verification.
Jesus invokes the Mosaic Law's requirement for two witnesses to establish truth, but elevates it by presenting Himself and the Father as divine witnesses, thereby exposing the legalistic and spiritually blind approach of his accusers.
c. 1400 BC
Torah Codified
The foundational laws of Israel, including principles for testimony, are given through Moses.
c. 750 BC
Prophetic Writings
Prophets like Isaiah and Jeremiah emphasize divine justice and the importance of truth in legal and spiritual matters.
c. 500 BC
Second Temple Period Begins
Following the Babylonian exile, Jewish religious and legal traditions are reinforced and codified in Jerusalem.
c. AD 30
Jesus' Ministry
Jesus begins his public ministry, teaching and performing miracles, often drawing on or correcting interpretations of the Law.
AD 30-33— this verse
Jesus' Teachings in the Temple
Jesus is teaching in the temple, the central place of Jewish worship and legal interpretation, directly challenging religious authorities.
This is the primary Old Testament passage Jesus is referencing, establishing the legal principle that a fact is established by the testimony of two or three witnesses.
Matthew 18:16Jesus himself reiterates this principle in the New Testament, showing its ongoing importance in establishing truth within the community of faith.
1 John 5:9This passage emphasizes that the witness of God is greater than the witness of men, directly paralleling Jesus' argument that His testimony, supported by the Father, is supremely valid.
Hebrews 1:1-3This passage highlights how God ultimately spoke through His Son, Jesus, framing Jesus' own testimony as a divine revelation that carries the weight of God's own word.
calvinJohn 8:15-20: "Ye judge after the flesh; I judge no man."
- You judge according to the flesh; I judge no man. 16. And if I judge, my judgment is true; [216] for I am not alone, but I and the Father, who hath sent me. 17. It is even written in your law, that the testimony of two men is true. 18. I am one who testify concerning myself, and the Father who hath sent me testifieth concerning me. 19. They said therefore to him, Where is thy Father? Jesus answered, You neither know me nor my Father.…
gillJohn 8:17: "It is also written in your law, that the testimony of two men is true."
It is also written in your law,.... The law of Moses, which was given unto them, and they boasted of; the passage referred to is in Deuteronomy 19:15 ; see also Deuteronomy 17:6 ; where though what follows is not to be found in so many words, yet the sense is there expressed: that the testimony of two men is true: concerning which the Jewish writers say (y), "they used not to determine any judiciary matter by th…
Jesus here isn't just quoting a legal principle; he's subtly highlighting that their "law" is being interpreted by people who are judging with human limitations ("according to the flesh"). He's pointing out that their own legal framework, which requires two witnesses to establish truth, is about to be fulfilled by two divine witnesses—Himself and the Father—thus exposing their narrow, earthly judgment as insufficient.
{ "studyTitle": "Two Witnesses: Divine Testimony in the Temple", "timeMinutes": 8, "concepts": [ { "title": "A Divine Legal Argument", "hook": "Jesus is in a heated debate with religious leaders. How does he use their own legal system against them?", "teaching": "Jesus is in the temple, teaching and being challenged by religious leaders. They are judging him based on their human understanding and traditions, what the scholars call 'judging according to the flesh.' This means they're focused on outward appearances and their own limited perspectives, rather than spiritual truth.\n\nJesus counters this by appealing to their own Law. He quotes Deuteronomy 19:15, which states that the testimony of two witnesses is considered true. This was a fundamental principle in their legal system to ensure fairness and prevent false accusations.\n\nJesus is setting up a profound argument: If their Law says two human witnesses are enough to establish truth, then surely the testimony of two divine witnesses—himself and the Father—should be more than sufficient to establish Jesus' identity and mission. He's essentially saying, 'You have a standard for truth, and I'm meeting it with witnesses far greater than any human ones.'", "readItAgain": "Notice how Jesus says, 'In your Law it is written that the testimony of two people is true.' He's directly referencing their own legal code.", "reflectionPrompt": "When you feel misunderstood or wrongly judged, how can you bring 'divine witnesses' like Scripture or prayer into your situation, rather than just relying on your own defense?", "supportingReferences": [ { "reference": "Deuteronomy 19:15", "connection": "This is the Old Testament passage Jesus is referencing, establishing the principle of two witnesses for legal matters." }, { "reference": "1 John 5:9", "connection": "This New Testament passage echoes the idea of God's testimony being greater than human testimony." } ] }, { "title": "Beyond Human Judgment", "hook": "The religious leaders are judging Jesus by their standards. But Jesus' judgment operates on a completely different level.", "teaching": "The religious leaders were focused on the 'flesh' – their own limited understanding, human traditions, and outward appearances. They couldn't comprehend Jesus' divine origin or mission. Jesus points this out, saying, 'You judge according to the flesh.'\n\nJesus, however, does not judge this way. While he could judge them, he states, 'I judge no one.' This isn't to say he is without judgment, but that his judgment isn't based on flawed human standards. As one scholar put it, he 'abstains from performing the office of a judge' at that moment, choosing instead to reveal truth.\n\nHe clarifies that 'if I do judge, my judgment is true, for I am not alone, but I and the Father who sent me.' This means his judgment is grounded in divine truth and is validated by the Father. His actions and teachings carry an authority that transcends human opinion or legalistic interpretation.", "readItAgain": "Consider Jesus' words: 'You judge according to the flesh; I judge no one. Yet if I do judge, my judgment is true, for I am not alone, but I and the Father who sent me.'", "reflectionPrompt": "How might our own 'judging according to the flesh' prevent us from recognizing God's truth or His work in others?", "supportingReferences": [ { "reference": "John 3:17", "connection": "This verse reinforces that Jesus came not to condemn but to save, highlighting his non-judgmental approach in his initial mission." }, { "reference": "1 Corinthians 2:14", "connection": "This verse contrasts the 'natural person' (thinking like those judging by the flesh) with spiritual understanding." } ] } ] }
{ "studyTitle": "Two Witnesses: Divine Testimony in the Temple", "timeMinutes": 8, "concepts": [ { "title": "A Divine Legal Argument", "hook": "Jesus is in a heated debate with religious leaders. How does he use their own legal system against them?", "teaching": "Jesus is in the temple, teaching and being challenged by religious leaders. They are judging him based on their human understanding and traditions, what the scholars call 'judging according to the flesh.' This means they're focused on outward appearances and their own limited perspectives, rather than spiritual truth.\n\nJesus counters this by appealing to their own Law. He quotes Deuteronomy 19:15, which states that the testimony of two witnesses is considered true. This was a fundamental principle in their legal system to ensure fairness and prevent false accusations.\n\nJesus is setting up a profound argument: If their Law says two human witnesses are enough to establish truth, then surely the testimony of two divine witnesses—himself and the Father—should be more than sufficient to establish Jesus' identity and mission. He's essentially saying, 'You have a standard for truth, and I'm meeting it with witnesses far greater than any human ones.'", "readItAgain": "Notice how Jesus says, 'In your Law it is written that the testimony of two people is true.' He's directly referencing their own legal code.", "reflectionPrompt": "When you feel misunderstood or wrongly judged, how can you bring 'divine witnesses' like Scripture or prayer into your situation, rather than just relying on your own defense?", "supportingReferences": [ { "reference": "Deuteronomy 19:15", "connection": "This is the Old Testament passage Jesus is referencing, establishing the principle of two witnesses for legal matters." }, { "reference": "1 John 5:9", "connection": "This New Testament passage echoes the idea of God's testimony being greater than human testimony." } ] }, { "title": "Beyond Human Judgment", "hook": "The religious leaders are judging Jesus by their standards. But Jesus' judgment operates on a completely different level.", "teaching": "The religious leaders were focused on the 'flesh' – their own limited understanding, human traditions, and outward appearances. They couldn't comprehend Jesus' divine origin or mission. Jesus points this out, saying, 'You judge according to the flesh.'\n\nJesus, however, does not judge this way. While he could judge them, he states, 'I judge no one.' This isn't to say he is without judgment, but that his judgment isn't based on flawed human standards. As one scholar put it, he 'abstains from performing the office of a judge' at that moment, choosing instead to reveal truth.\n\nHe clarifies that 'if I do judge, my judgment is true, for I am not alone, but I and the Father who sent me.' This means his judgment is grounded in divine truth and is validated by the Father. His actions and teachings carry an authority that transcends human opinion or legalistic interpretation.", "readItAgain": "Consider Jesus' words: 'You judge according to the flesh; I judge no one. Yet if I do judge, my judgment is true, for I am not alone, but I and the Father who sent me.'", "reflectionPrompt": "How might our own 'judging according to the flesh' prevent us from recognizing God's truth or His work in others?", "supportingReferences": [ { "reference": "John 3:17", "connection": "This verse reinforces that Jesus came not to condemn but to save, highlighting his non-judgmental approach in his initial mission." }, { "reference": "1 Corinthians 2:14", "connection": "This verse contrasts the 'natural person' (thinking like those judging by the flesh) with spiritual understanding." } ] } ] }
"In your Law it is written that the testimony of two people is true." — Jesus here isn't just quoting a legal principle; he's subtly highlighting that their "law" is being interpreted by people who are judging with human limitations ("according to the flesh"). He's point…
Get the original Greek and Hebrew, verse-by-verse context, and related passages inside the app.