John 18:38
Pilate said to him, “What is truth?” After he had said this, he went back outside to the Jews and told them, “I find no guilt in him.
English Standard Version (ESV)
This page isn't yet indexed by search engines.
Pilate's dismissive question, "What is truth?" isn't a genuine inquiry, but a worldly shrug, revealing his inability to grasp Jesus' spiritual kingdom, and his immediate departure underscores his utter indifference to finding any real answers. He was convinced of Jesus' innocence, not by understanding His truth, but by the sheer lack of any political threat.
Jesus has just explained to Pilate that his kingdom is not of this world, but is a spiritual reality focused on truth. Pilate, a Roman governor accustomed to earthly power and politics, dismisses Jesus' claims with a cynical question, "What is truth?" before immediately turning back to the crowd to declare Jesus innocent. This happens in the midst of the Passover festival, as Pilate grapples with the political implications of Jesus' claim to kingship while trying to appease the Jewish leaders.
Pilate famously asks, "What is truth?" but Jesus' answer reveals truth isn't just an idea, but a Person.
When Pilate asks, "What is truth?" he's likely dismissing Jesus' claims about his kingdom. He sees truth as a philosophical concept, perhaps irrelevant to the political realities he deals with every day. But Jesus, in His response, has already defined truth not as an abstract idea, but as a Person – Himself!
Jesus had just told Pilate, "For this I was born, and for this I came into the world, to testify to the truth. Everyone on the side of truth listens to me." (John 18:37). He isn't just talking about a set of beliefs; He is presenting Himself as the embodiment of all truth. His kingdom isn't of this world because its foundation and ruler are Truth itself.
Pilate's question, "What is truth?" wasn't a genuine search, but a sign of his world-weary skepticism.
Pilate's question isn't born out of a deep, honest yearning to understand truth. Instead, the context suggests it's a cynical, perhaps even scornful, dismissal. He's a Roman governor, used to dealing with power, politics, and pragmatism. Jesus' talk of a kingdom not of this world and bearing witness to "truth" seems abstract and impractical to him. He sees it as irrelevant to the real world of Roman authority and Jewish unrest. He's not looking for an answer; he's shutting down the conversation because it doesn't fit his worldview.
This reflects a common human tendency: to treat profound truths as mere philosophical puzzles or to dismiss them because they don't align with our immediate, earthly concerns. Pilate's "good-nature" or "weak and shallow good-nature," as some commentators note, is ultimately indifference, a refusal to engage with something that challenges his established perspective.
Despite his profound question about truth, Pilate declared Jesus innocent. Yet, he still handed Him over.
What's striking is what Pilate does immediately after his cynical question. He goes out and declares, 'I find no guilt in him.' This is a powerful, official pronouncement of Jesus' innocence. From a legal and moral standpoint, Jesus should have been released. Pilate, the secular authority, found no fault.
Understand the original words
aitia · Greek Noun
A legal or moral fault; innocence or lack of blameworthiness, used here to declare that the accused had committed no violation of the law.
Pilate's dismissive question, 'What is truth?', highlights the profound disconnect between the eternal, spiritual reality Jesus presented and the pragmatic, political concerns of the Roman governor.
c. AD 27-30
Jesus' Ministry and Growing Accusations
Jesus' teachings and miracles gain a following, drawing the attention and ire of religious leaders who see him as a threat.
c. AD 30, Passover Week
Jesus' Arrest and Trials
Jesus is arrested after the Last Supper, leading to a series of trials before the Sanhedrin, Herod Antipas, and finally Pontius Pilate.
c. AD 30, Passover Week— this verse
Pilate's Examination of Jesus
Pilate questions Jesus about his claim to be 'King of the Jews,' leading to Jesus' declaration about his kingdom not being of this world and his identity as 'the truth.' Pilate, weary and dismissive, asks 'What is truth?' and then declares he finds no guilt in Jesus.
c. AD 30, Passover Week
The Crowd Demands Barabbas
Following Jesus' declaration of innocence, Pilate offers the crowd a choice between Jesus and Barabbas, a known criminal. The crowd, incited by the chief priests, demands Barabbas' release and Jesus' crucifixion.
This passage directly contrasts worldly wisdom with God's wisdom, mirroring Pilate's inability to grasp Jesus' spiritual truth and his reliance on pragmatic, worldly judgment.
Proverbs 12:22This proverb speaks about the delight of the Lord in those who are true, contrasting sharply with Pilate's dismissive attitude towards 'truth' itself.
Jesus' own declaration, 'I am the way, and the truth, and the life,' is the ultimate answer to Pilate's question, highlighting that Jesus embodies the very truth Pilate sought to dismiss.
This verse explains that knowing and living by truth (Jesus' word) sets one free, underscoring the profound, liberating power of the truth that Pilate carelessly questioned.
Matthew 27:24This verse shows Pilate's ultimate capitulation to the crowd's demands despite his own conviction of Jesus' innocence, illustrating the tragic consequence of prioritizing expediency over truth.
henryJohn 18:33-40: "Then Pilate entered into the judgment hall again, and called Jesus, and said unto him, Art thou the King of the Jews?"
18:33-40 Art thou the King of the Jews? that King of the Jews who has been so long expected? Messiah the Prince; art thou he? Dost thou call thyself so, and wouldest thou be thought so? Christ answered this question with another; not for evasion, but that Pilate might consider what he did. He never took upon him any earthly power, never were any traitorous princ…
wesleyJohn 18:38: "Pilate saith unto him, What is truth? And when he had said this, he went out again unto the Jews, and saith unto them, I find in him no fault at all."
18:38 What is truth? - Said Pilate, a courtier; perhaps meaning what signifies truth? Is that a thing worth hazarding your life for? So he left him presently, to plead with the Jews for him, looking upon him as an innocent but weak man.
Pilate's dismissive question, "What is truth?" isn't a genuine inquiry, but a worldly shrug, revealing his inability to grasp Jesus' spiritual kingdom, and his immediate departure underscores his utter indifference to finding any real answers. He was convinced of Jesus' innocence, not by understanding His truth, but by the sheer lack of any political threat.
Jesus has just explained to Pilate that his kingdom is not of this world, but is a spiritual reality focused on truth. Pilate, a Roman governor accustomed to earthly power and politics, dismisses Jesus' claims with a cynical question, "What is truth?" before immediately turning back to the crowd to declare Jesus innocent. This happens in the midst of the Passover festival, as Pilate grapples with the political implications of Jesus' claim to kingship while trying to appease the Jewish leaders.
Jesus has just explained to Pilate that his kingdom is not of this world, but is a spiritual reality focused on truth. Pilate, a Roman governor accustomed to earthly power and politics, dismisses Jesus' claims with a cynical question, "What is truth?" before immediately turning back to the crowd to declare Jesus innocent. This happens in the midst of the Passover festival, as Pilate grapples with the political implications of Jesus' claim to kingship while trying to appease the Jewish leaders.
Get the original Greek and Hebrew, verse-by-verse context, and related passages inside the app.
Ask a follow-up
Ask Sola things like:
Live chat about John 18:38 is available in the Sola app.
However, Pilate's declaration isn't the end of the story. He allows the escalating pressure from the Jewish leaders and the crowd to sway his decision. His acknowledgment of Jesus' innocence is ultimately overridden by his desire to appease the mob and avoid political trouble. This reveals a tragic tension: the truth of Jesus' innocence is recognized, but justice is denied due to human fear, compromise, and the rejection of divine truth by those in power.
c. AD 30, Passover Week
Crucifixion of Jesus
Despite finding no guilt, Pilate succumbs to the pressure and condemns Jesus to crucifixion, washing his hands as a symbolic act of disavowing responsibility.
"Pilate said to him, “What is truth?”
After he had said this, he went back outside to the Jews and told them, “I find no guilt in him." — Pilate's dismissive question, "What is truth?" isn't a genuine inquiry, but a worldly shrug, revealing his inability to grasp Jesus' spiritual kingdom, and his immediate departure underscores his utt…
