Job 12:2
“No doubt you are the people, and wisdom will die with you.
English Standard Version (ESV)
Job 12:2
“No doubt you are the people, and wisdom will die with you.
English Standard Version (ESV)
This page isn't yet indexed by search engines.
Job's words here are dripping with sarcasm. He's not actually saying his friends are the pinnacle of wisdom; he's mocking their arrogant assumption that all knowledge rests with them, and that when they're gone, the world will be devoid of wisdom. This biting irony highlights their self-importance and dismissiveness towards him.
Job is responding to his friends, who have been offering him advice and judgment, assuming they possess all the wisdom. He sarcastically addresses them, implying they believe all wisdom will die with them, and that only they understand true righteousness and suffering. This statement highlights his frustration with their self-righteousness and their inability to grasp God’s complex purposes.
Job's friends have come to comfort him, but their words feel more like accusations. What's behind Job's cutting sarcasm in calling them 'the people'?
Job uses biting irony here. When he says, “No doubt you are the people,” he's not actually praising them. The context shows they've been speaking with great confidence, acting like they possess all the wisdom in the world. Job is sarcastically agreeing with their self-assessment, highlighting their arrogance and their failure to truly comfort him. It’s a way of saying, 'Oh yes, you’re so wise, aren't you?'
Job’s friends are acting like their understanding is the final word. Job calls them out on a dangerous assumption they seem to hold about their own knowledge.
The second part of Job's statement, 'and wisdom will die with you,' is the core of his critique. His friends aren't just proud; they're acting as if their specific brand of wisdom is the only true wisdom, and that it will be lost to the world when they’re gone. This reveals a profound self-importance. Job is pointing out that true wisdom, ultimately God's wisdom, doesn't depend on any single person or group. It’s a warning against thinking our own understanding is so unique and irreplaceable that the world couldn’t possibly go on without it.
Understand the original words
chokmah · Hebrew Noun
Refers to the capacity for discernment, insight, and the practical application of knowledge, particularly in relation to God and His ways. It is often associated with the fear of the Lord and the ability to distinguish between right and wrong or true and false.
Paul sarcastically echoes Job's sentiment, questioning where the 'wise' and 'intelligent' are in God's economy, highlighting that God's wisdom often appears foolish to the world.
Romans 10:19This verse directly uses the concept of 'people' and 'understanding,' noting that Israel, despite supposed wisdom, did not truly comprehend God's ways, serving as a parallel to Job's friends' misplaced confidence.
Proverbs 26:12This proverb warns against self-perceived wisdom, stating that a fool who thinks he is wise is far worse than one who recognizes his folly, a sentiment Job directs at his friends.
Isaiah 40:13-14This passage contrasts human pride and perceived wisdom with God's unfathomable knowledge, reinforcing Job's underlying point that true wisdom belongs to God alone, not to mortals.
bensonJob 12:2: "No doubt but ye are the people, and wisdom shall die with you."
Job 12:2. No doubt but ye are the people — You, of all people, are the most eminent for wisdom; the only men living of distinguished knowledge and prudence. You have engrossed all the reason of mankind, and each of you has as much wisdom as a whole people put together. And wisdom shall die with you — All the wisdom which is in the world lives in you, and will be utterly lost when you die. When wise and good men die, it i…
pooleJob 12:2: "No doubt but ye are the people, and wisdom shall die with you."
Ye are the people; you three, and you only, are the people , i.e. people of all people for eminency of wisdom, the only company of reasonable creatures; all others are but fools or beasts: you have engrossed all the reason of mankind; and each of you have as much wisdom as a whole people put together. It is an ironical expression, as the next verse showeth. Wisdom shall die with you; all the wisdom and knowledge of Divin…
Job's words here are dripping with sarcasm. He's not actually saying his friends are the pinnacle of wisdom; he's mocking their arrogant assumption that all knowledge rests with them, and that when they're gone, the world will be devoid of wisdom. This biting irony highlights their self-importance and dismissiveness towards him.
Job is responding to his friends, who have been offering him advice and judgment, assuming they possess all the wisdom. He sarcastically addresses them, implying they believe all wisdom will die with them, and that only they understand true righteousness and suffering. This statement highlights his frustration with their self-righteousness and their inability to grasp God’s complex purposes.
Job is responding to his friends, who have been offering him advice and judgment, assuming they possess all the wisdom. He sarcastically addresses them, implying they believe all wisdom will die with them, and that only they understand true righteousness and suffering. This statement highlights his frustration with their self-righteousness and their inability to grasp God’s complex purposes.
Get the original Greek and Hebrew, verse-by-verse context, and related passages inside the app.
Ask a follow-up
Ask Sola things like:
Live chat about Job 12:2 is available in the Sola app.
"“No doubt you are the people, and wisdom will die with you." — Job's words here are dripping with sarcasm. He's not actually saying his friends are the pinnacle of wisdom; he's mocking their arrogant assumption that all knowledge rests with them, and that when t…