Jeremiah 22:10-12
This page isn't yet indexed by search engines.
The verse contrasts the finality of death with the deeper sorrow of irreversible exile. While death offers an escape from impending judgment and a return to God, being carried away into captivity means losing one's homeland forever, a fate far more tragic for those left behind to witness it.
Weep not for him who is dead, nor grieve for him, but weep bitterly for him who goes away, for he shall return no more to see his native land. For thus says the LORD concerning Shallum the son of Josiah, king of Judah, who reigned instead of Josiah his father, and who went away from this place: “He shall return here no more, but in the place where they have carried him captive, there shall he die, and he shall never see this land again.”
English Standard Version (ESV)
The prophet Jeremiah begins a new section, looking back at the recent reigns and delivering judgment. He contrasts the death of the righteous King Josiah, who escaped the coming destruction, with the fate of his son Jehoahaz (also called Shallum). Jehoahaz was a young king who reigned only three months before being taken captive to Egypt by Pharaoh Necho, from which he would never return.
Sometimes, the greatest sorrow isn't for those who have died, but for those who are taken away from everything they've ever known.
Jeremiah distinguishes between two kinds of loss: death and exile. He tells the people not to grieve excessively for the dead, even a beloved king like Josiah. Why? Because death, for the righteous, is an escape from coming troubles and a transition to peace.
However, for the one 'going away' – in this case, King Jehoahaz, who was exiled to Egypt – the prophet urges bitter tears. This isn't just sadness; it's a profound mourning for a life irrevocably severed from home, land, and future. Exile meant a complete loss of identity and belonging, a fate far worse than a peaceful death.
Death can sometimes be a mercy, sparing individuals from witnessing or experiencing future devastation.
The commentary highlights a crucial theological point: Josiah, a righteous king, was killed in battle. While his death was tragic, Jeremiah implies it was also a blessing. By dying when he did, Josiah was spared from witnessing the horrific descent of his nation into further sin and subsequent judgment under his wicked successors and the coming Babylonian exile.
This perspective challenges our typical view of death. Instead of always seeing it as the ultimate tragedy, Scripture sometimes presents it, for the faithful, as a peaceful departure, a removal from impending hardship. The emphasis shifts from mourning the departed to lamenting the dire circumstances of the living.
Understand the original words
Ask a follow-up
bakah · Hebrew Verb
An outward expression of deep internal sorrow, lamentation, or mourning, often associated with tragedy, death, or severe divine judgment.
YHWH · Hebrew Proper Noun
The personal name of the covenant God of Israel. It denotes His self-existence, eternal nature, and His faithfulness to His redemptive covenant with His people.
shebiy · Hebrew Noun
A state of being taken into custody or forced into a foreign land, often as a result of divine judgment for disobedience to God’s covenant. It represents the reversal of the blessings of the promised land.
This verse contrasts the sorrow for a righteous king (Josiah) who died, with a far greater lament for a king (Jehoahaz) who goes into exile, highlighting the devastating consequences of political turmoil and foreign domination for Judah.
609 BC
Death of King Josiah
King Josiah, a righteous ruler, is killed in battle against Pharaoh Necho of Egypt at Megiddo. His death is a profound shock and sorrow to the people of Judah.
609 BC
Jehoahaz (Shallum) becomes King
The people of Judah choose Josiah's younger son, Shallum, to succeed him. He takes the throne name Jehoahaz and reigns for only three months.
609 BC— this verse
Pharaoh Necho deposes Jehoahaz
Pharaoh Necho deposes King Jehoahaz after a short reign and takes him captive to Egypt, never to return to his homeland.
609 BC
Jehoiakim becomes King
Pharaoh Necho installs Jehoiakim, Jehoahaz's older brother (formerly Eliakim), as king of Judah, making Judah a vassal state of Egypt.
605 BC
Battle of Carchemish
The Babylonian Empire, under Nebuchadnezzar, decisively defeats the Egyptian and Assyrian forces, establishing Babylonian dominance over the region.
c. 605 BC
First Babylonian Deportation
Nebuchadnezzar deports a portion of the Judean elite, including the prophet Daniel, to Babylon, marking the beginning of Judah's subjugation to Babylon.
This passage describes King Josiah's death in battle, the very event Jeremiah tells his listeners *not* to weep over, as it spared him from seeing the coming destruction.
2 Kings 23:31-34This passage details the fate of Jehoahaz, the 'one who goes away,' being taken captive to Egypt by Pharaoh Necho, directly illustrating the prophet's point about a more grievous fate than death.
Ezekiel 19:1-4This prophetic lament describes a young lion (likened to Jehoahaz) being captured and taken to Egypt, echoing Jeremiah's sorrow over the exiled king who would not return.
Ecclesiastes 4:2This verse reflects a similar sentiment that the dead, who are at rest, are to be envied compared to the living who suffer, aligning with Jeremiah's contrast between mourning for the dead and grieving for the exiled.
barnesJeremiah 22:10: "Weep ye not for the dead, neither bemoan him: but weep sore for him that goeth away: for he shall return no more, nor see his native country."
In the two foregoing prophecies Jeremiah stated the general principle on which depend the rise and downfall of kings and nations. He now adds for Zedekiah's warning the history of three thrones which were not established. The first is that of Shallum the successor of Josiah, who probably took the name of Jehoahaz on his accession (see th…
gillJeremiah 22:10: "Weep ye not for the dead, neither bemoan him: but weep sore for him that goeth away: for he shall return no more, nor see his native country."
Weep ye not for the dead, neither bemoan him,.... Not Jehoiakim, as Jarchi and Kimchi; but King Josiah, slain by Pharaohnecho; who, being a pious prince, a good king, and very useful, and much beloved by his people, great lamentation was made for him by them, and by the prophet also; but now he exhorts them to cease weeping, or at least…
The verse contrasts the finality of death with the deeper sorrow of irreversible exile. While death offers an escape from impending judgment and a return to God, being carried away into captivity means losing one's homeland forever, a fate far more tragic for those left behind to witness it.
The prophet Jeremiah begins a new section, looking back at the recent reigns and delivering judgment. He contrasts the death of the righteous King Josiah, who escaped the coming destruction, with the fate of his son Jehoahaz (also called Shallum). Jehoahaz was a young king who reigned only three months before being taken captive to Egypt by Pharaoh Necho, from which he would never return.
The prophet Jeremiah begins a new section, looking back at the recent reigns and delivering judgment. He contrasts the death of the righteous King Josiah, who escaped the coming destruction, with the fate of his son Jehoahaz (also called Shallum). Jehoahaz was a young king who reigned only three months before being taken captive to Egypt by Pharaoh Necho, from which he would never return.
"Weep not for him who is dead, nor grieve for him, but weep bitterly for him who goes away, for he shall return no more to see his native land. For thus says the LORD concerning Shallum the son of Josiah, king of…" — The verse contrasts the finality of death with the deeper sorrow of irreversible exile. While death offers an escape from impending judgment and a return to God, being carried away into captivity mea…
Get the original Greek and Hebrew, verse-by-verse context, and related passages inside the app.
Last reviewed October 2026
