Your silver has become dross, your best wine mixed with water.
English Standard Version (ESV)
The imagery contrasts genuine value with a deceptive appearance. "Silver" once represented purity and worth, but it has degenerated into "dross" – worthless refuse. Similarly, the "wine," symbolizing vitality and richness, is now diluted with "water," signifying impurity and weakness.
Your silver has become dross, your best wine mixed with water.
English Standard Version (ESV)
Jerusalem, once a city known for its justice, has fallen into deep corruption under its leaders. As the Assyrian army, led by Sennacherib, looms on the horizon, panic and profligacy grip the city. Instead of turning to God, the people have embraced superficial religious practices and a reckless "eat, drink, and be merry" attitude, believing deliverance is impossible. This verse highlights that the city's once precious resources, symbolized by silver and wine, have been debased by this moral and spiritual decay.
Imagine a vibrant, rich wine, the kind that warms you from the inside out. Now, imagine that wine has been watered down, its essence diluted, its strength gone. That's the picture Isaiah paints for us.
Isaiah uses two powerful images to describe the spiritual state of Jerusalem: 'Your silver has become dross, your best wine mixed with water.'
Dross Instead of Silver
Think of the purest silver, gleaming and valuable. Now, imagine it's been mixed with impurities, heated and cooled until it's no longer precious but worthless refuse – dross. This isn't just about money; it's about the very character of the city and its leaders. What was once pure, valuable, and trustworthy has become corrupted and debased.
Watered-Down Wine
'Your best wine mixed with water' speaks to a similar corruption, but in the realm of life and vitality. Pure, strong wine could refresh and strengthen. But when mixed with water, it loses its power. It's no longer truly wine; it's a pale imitation. This represents spiritual life, truth, and faithfulness that has been diluted. The things that should have invigorated and sustained the people – their justice, their worship, their leaders' integrity – have been weakened and made ineffective by compromises and impurity.
Who are the 'silver' and 'wine' in our society today? Often, we look to leaders, those in positions of authority, for purity and strength. But what happens when they fail?
Ask a follow-up
The prophet Isaiah isn't just speaking generally; he's pointing a finger at those in charge. The commentators highlight that this imagery of debased silver and watered-down wine primarily describes the rulers and leaders of Jerusalem.
Corrupted Guardians
These leaders were meant to be like pure silver, reflecting God's justice and integrity. They were supposed to be the strong, life-giving 'wine' that would sustain the people. Instead, they had become like dross – worthless and corrupt. They had allowed impurity and dishonesty to seep into their governance, weakening the spiritual and moral fabric of the nation.
The Ripple Effect
When leaders compromise their values and dilute the truth, it has a devastating ripple effect. Their corruption isn't an isolated incident; it pollutes the entire community. The 'best wine' of spiritual life and true worship becomes mixed with the 'water' of human traditions, compromises, and outright sin. This is why the passage speaks of a general deterioration – the whole city's character was compromised because its leaders failed.
Understand the original words
sig · Hebrew Noun
Refers to the waste or scum removed from metal during the refining process. Metaphorically, it represents worthlessness, corruption, and the loss of purity.
The imagery of 'silver turned to dross' and 'wine mixed with water' powerfully reflects the moral and spiritual corruption of Jerusalem's leaders and people during the siege of 701 BC. Faced with invasion, their former purity and strength had degraded into worthlessness and dilution, making them unfit for the crucial moment.
c. 760 BC
Beginning of Isaiah's Ministry
Isaiah receives his prophetic calling during the reign of King Uzziah of Judah, a time of prosperity but also growing moral and spiritual decline.
c. 734-732 BC
Syro-Ephraimite War
The northern kingdom of Israel (Ephraim) and Syria attack Judah. Isaiah advises King Ahaz to trust God, not Assyria, a counsel rejected.
c. 722 BC
Fall of Samaria
The Northern Kingdom of Israel is conquered and its people exiled by the Assyrian Empire, a stark warning to Judah.
c. 705 BC
Assyrian Campaigns Intensify
After a period of relative peace under King Hezekiah, Sennacherib becomes king of Assyria and begins aggressive campaigns in the Levant.
701 BC— this verse
Sennacherib's Invasion of Judah
Sennacherib invades Judah, conquering many cities and besieging Jerusalem. The prophet Isaiah delivers God's message to Hezekiah and the people.
This passage uses similar imagery of metals and their impurities to describe a nation's moral decay and unresponsiveness to God's judgment, mirroring the 'dross' and dilution described in Isaiah.
Ezekiel 22:17-22This passage describes Jerusalem as 'dross' among the furnace, with metals like silver and iron mixed with it, also speaking of refining by fire, which parallels Isaiah's critique of impurities within the nation.
Proverbs 9:1-2Proverbs describes wisdom as having 'killed her beasts' and 'mixed her wine,' contrasting with Isaiah's imagery. This highlights how what should be pure and strengthening (wisdom, pure wine) has become corrupted and diluted in Jerusalem.
Matthew 5:13Jesus uses the metaphor of salt losing its savor to describe a similar state of uselessness and spiritual dilution among his followers, reflecting the idea that something once valuable has become ineffective and impure.
pooleIsaiah 1:22: "Thy silver is become dross, thy wine mixed with water:"
Thou art woefully degenerated from thy former purity. If there be any remainders of religion and justice in thee, they are mixed with many and great corruptions.
expositorsIsaiah 1:22: "Thy silver is become dross, thy wine mixed with water:"
CHAPTER XIXAT THE LOWEST EBB Isaiah 1:1 ; Isaiah 22:1-25 IN the drama of Isaiah’s life we have now arrived at the final act-a short and sharp one of a few months. The time is 701 B.C., the fortieth year of Isaiah’s ministry, and about the twenty-sixth of Hezekiah’s reign. The background is the invasion of Palestine by Sennacherib. The stage itself is the city of Jerusalem. In the clear atmosphere before the bursting of the st…
The imagery contrasts genuine value with a deceptive appearance. "Silver" once represented purity and worth, but it has degenerated into "dross" – worthless refuse. Similarly, the "wine," symbolizing vitality and richness, is now diluted with "water," signifying impurity and weakness.
Jerusalem, once a city known for its justice, has fallen into deep corruption under its leaders. As the Assyrian army, led by Sennacherib, looms on the horizon, panic and profligacy grip the city. Instead of turning to God, the people have embraced superficial religious practices and a reckless "eat, drink, and be merry" attitude, believing deliverance is impossible. This verse highlights that the city's once precious resources, symbolized by silver and wine, have been debased by this moral and spiritual decay.
Jerusalem, once a city known for its justice, has fallen into deep corruption under its leaders. As the Assyrian army, led by Sennacherib, looms on the horizon, panic and profligacy grip the city. Instead of turning to God, the people have embraced superficial religious practices and a reckless "eat, drink, and be merry" attitude, believing deliverance is impossible. This verse highlights that the city's once precious resources, symbolized by silver and wine, have been debased by this moral and spiritual decay.
"Your silver has become dross, your best wine mixed with water." — The imagery contrasts genuine value with a deceptive appearance. "Silver" once represented purity and worth, but it has degenerated into "dross" – worthless refuse. Similarly, the "wine," symbolizing…
Get the original Greek and Hebrew, verse-by-verse context, and related passages inside the app.
Last reviewed October 2026