Genesis 44:17
But he said, “Far be it from me that I should do so! Only the man in whose hand the cup was found shall be my servant. But as for you, go up in peace to your father.”
English Standard Version (ESV)
This page isn't yet indexed by search engines.
Joseph, disguised as an Egyptian official, declares that he would never take Benjamin as a slave based on the circumstances. Instead, he insists that only the one found with the cup will become his servant, allowing the rest to return to their father in peace. This subtle shift in Joseph's decree underscores his ultimate goal: not punishment, but to discern the true heart and brotherly love of his siblings.
After the steward reveals that the silver cup was found in Benjamin’s sack, Joseph's brothers are devastated and return to him in despair. Judah then steps forward to plead for Benjamin's release, offering himself as a slave in Benjamin's place and recounting their aged father's deep love for his youngest son. In response, Joseph, deeply moved, declares that he will not keep them all as slaves, but only Benjamin, while allowing the rest to return home to their father.
When faced with a choice that seems to demand harsh justice, Joseph offers a surprising alternative. What does this reveal about his heart?
Joseph's response, "God forbid that I should do so," is a powerful declaration against the easy path of retribution. He rejects the idea of punishing all the brothers for Benjamin's supposed crime.
This isn't just a polite refusal; it's a moral and spiritual stance. It shows that Joseph has moved beyond his own pain and is now acting not out of personal vengeance, but with a deeper sense of justice and even mercy.
He proposes a specific, limited consequence: only the one found with the cup will be his servant. This targeted justice contrasts sharply with the indiscriminate punishment the brothers might have feared.
Joseph sends the majority of his brothers back home, but holds one back. What is the significance of this dual outcome?
Joseph's declaration, "as for you, get you up in peace to your father," is an act of profound grace towards the ten older brothers. They are released from their fear and suspicion, allowed to return home with their provisions, and their integrity is affirmed.
Ask a follow-up
Ask Sola things like:
Live chat about Genesis 44:17 is available in the Sola app.
However, Benjamin is singled out to remain as a servant. This might seem harsh, but it serves a crucial purpose in Joseph's plan. It's not about punishing Benjamin, but about confronting the brothers with their past actions and their present character.
This outcome highlights the different stages of their journey. The ten have passed a significant test of loyalty and love for Benjamin, demonstrating their changed hearts. Benjamin, being the focus of their loyalty, is the one held to allow this transformation to fully solidify and to set the stage for reconciliation.
Understand the original words
shalom · Hebrew Noun
A state of wholeness, well-being, harmony, and prosperity, often denoting a divine blessing of safety and spiritual contentment given by God to His people.
This moment is the culmination of Joseph's elaborate plan to test his brothers' character after twenty years of separation. Their willingness to sacrifice themselves for Benjamin reveals their profound change and repentance, allowing Joseph to finally reveal himself.
c. 1750 BC
Joseph sold into slavery
Joseph, son of Jacob, is sold into slavery by his envious brothers and eventually rises to a position of power in Egypt.
c. 1730 BC
Famine strikes Canaan
A severe famine forces Joseph's brothers to travel from Canaan to Egypt to buy grain, unknowingly encountering Joseph as the Egyptian governor.
c. 1730 BC
Brothers' first visit to Egypt
Joseph tests his brothers, holding Simeon captive until they promise to return with their youngest brother, Benjamin.
c. 1730 BC— this verse
Brothers' second visit to Egypt
The brothers return with Benjamin, and Joseph devises a plan to test their loyalty by framing Benjamin for stealing his prized silver cup.
c. 1730 BC
Judah's plea for Benjamin
After Benjamin is accused, Judah passionately pleads with Joseph, offering himself as a slave in Benjamin's place to save his younger brother and their father from despair.
This passage also addresses the consequences of theft and the differing punishments for common people and those in authority, reflecting the differentiated response Joseph offers his brothers.
1 Samuel 26:18David's humble reply to Saul, 'Why does my father pursue after his servant?' echoes the brothers' respectful and submissive tone when addressing Joseph as 'my lord'.
Romans 12:19Paul's exhortation to 'never avenge yourselves, but rather give place unto wrath' resonates with Joseph's restraint from immediate retribution and his allowing God's justice to unfold.
Matthew 18:21-22Peter's question about forgiving seven times and Jesus' response of seventy-seven times highlight the immense capacity for forgiveness that Joseph demonstrates towards his brothers.
Genesis 50:20This verse, spoken by Joseph himself, directly states his perspective that 'you meant evil against me; but God meant it for good,' providing the ultimate theological framework for his actions and his response here.
gillGenesis 44:17: "And he said, God forbid that I should do so: but the man in whose hand the cup is found, he shall be my servant; and as for you, get you up in peace unto your father."
And he said, God forbid that I should do so,.... This would be doing an unjust thing, Joseph suggests, should he take them all for bondmen, for the offence of one: but the man in whose hand the cup is found, he shall be my servant; not die, as they had supposed, but become his servant: and as for you, get ye up in…
calvinGenesis 44:1-34: "And he commanded the steward of his house, saying, Fill the men's sacks with food, as much as they can carry, and put every man's money in his sack's mouth."
And put my cup, the silver cup, in the sack's mouth of the youngest, and his corn money. And he did according to the word that Joseph had spoken.
Et scyphum meum, scyphum argenteum, pone in ore saccijunioris, et pecuniam alimenti ejus: et fecit secundum verbum Joseph, quod loquutus fuerat.
As soon as the mornin…
Joseph, disguised as an Egyptian official, declares that he would never take Benjamin as a slave based on the circumstances. Instead, he insists that only the one found with the cup will become his servant, allowing the rest to return to their father in peace. This subtle shift in Joseph's decree underscores his ultimate goal: not punishment, but to discern the true heart and brotherly love of his siblings.
After the steward reveals that the silver cup was found in Benjamin’s sack, Joseph's brothers are devastated and return to him in despair. Judah then steps forward to plead for Benjamin's release, offering himself as a slave in Benjamin's place and recounting their aged father's deep love for his youngest son. In response, Joseph, deeply moved, declares that he will not keep them all as slaves, but only Benjamin, while allowing the rest to return home to their father.
After the steward reveals that the silver cup was found in Benjamin’s sack, Joseph's brothers are devastated and return to him in despair. Judah then steps forward to plead for Benjamin's release, offering himself as a slave in Benjamin's place and recounting their aged father's deep love for his youngest son. In response, Joseph, deeply moved, declares that he will not keep them all as slaves, but only Benjamin, while allowing the rest to return home to their father.
"But he said, “Far be it from me that I should do so! Only the man in whose hand the cup was found shall be my servant. But as for you, go up in peace to your father.”" — Joseph, disguised as an Egyptian official, declares that he would never take Benjamin as a slave based on the circumstances. Instead, he insists that only the one found with the cup will become his s…
Get the original Greek and Hebrew, verse-by-verse context, and related passages inside the app.
