Ecclesiastes 4:7-9
Again, I saw vanity under the sun: one person who has no other, either son or brother, yet there is no end to all his toil, and his eyes are never satisfied with riches, so that he never asks, “For whom am I toiling and depriving myself of pleasure?” This also is vanity and an unhappy business. Two are better than one, because they have a good reward for their toil.
English Standard Version (ESV)
This page isn't yet indexed by search engines.
This verse doesn't just present a general observation of futility; it's a specific turn in the Preacher's reflection. He's returning to his contemplation, and what he now sees is the profound emptiness of a life consumed by ceaseless, solitary accumulation, a drive for more that never finds satisfaction.
Solomon has just observed the futility of working endlessly without finding enjoyment, especially if one is alone. Now, he turns his attention to a different kind of emptiness: the endless pursuit of wealth by someone who has no one to share it with, not even family. This lonely, greedy individual toils relentlessly, yet never finds contentment, ultimately leaving it all to others.
The verse says 'Again, I saw vanity under the sun.' What kind of 'vanity' is the Preacher seeing now?
The Preacher isn't just observing general emptiness; he's pinpointing a specific human tendency: the relentless, unsatisfying pursuit of more.
The Empty Cup
Commentators note that this passage highlights avarice – a deep, often selfish, longing for wealth and possessions. It's the mindset of 'the more I have, the more I want.' This desire isn't about meeting needs; it's about accumulation for its own sake, often leading to a lack of contentment.
Isolation and Insecurity
This grasping for more often leads to isolation. The commentaries mention a 'solitary man' or one who is 'brotherless, childless.' When our focus is solely on acquiring, we can neglect relationships, leaving us alone with our possessions, with no one to share them with or to care for us.
No Real Enjoyment
Ultimately, this insatiable desire robs us of joy. Even with abundance, such a person 'get[s] no enjoyment from what they have.' The pursuit itself becomes the focus, leaving no room for appreciating the present or finding satisfaction.
The verse states 'Again, I saw vanity under the sun.' What specific scenario illustrates this vanity?
This verse, especially when read in context with the following ones, paints a picture of a specific kind of futility: the lonely accumulation of wealth.
The Lone Achiever
The commentaries point to the idea of a 'solitary man' or someone without close family ties ('brotherless, childless'). This isn't just about being single; it's about a life so focused on personal gain that it excludes or neglects deep, meaningful relationships.
Wealth Without Legacy
Understand the original words
hebel · Hebrew Noun
A Hebrew concept often translated as 'vanity,' referring to that which is fleeting, unsubstantial, enigmatic, or transitory, much like a vapor or breath. It describes the frustrating limitations of life in a fallen, post-Eden world.
tachat hashemesh · Hebrew Prepositional Phrase
A descriptive phrase unique to Ecclesiastes referring to life on earth, specifically human existence characterized by human perspective, earthly limitations, and the inevitable reality of death apart from divine perspective.
This verse echoes the lament of Ecclesiastes 4:7 by stating that all human labor is driven by an insatiable appetite, highlighting the endless, unfulfilling cycle of desire.
Matthew 6:24Jesus directly addresses the 'vanity' of serving two masters, wealth and God, showing that prioritizing material gain over spiritual devotion leads to an unfulfilled life, just as the Preacher observes.
1 Timothy 6:10This passage warns that the love of money is a root of all kinds of evil, a sentiment that resonates with the Preacher's observation of avarice and isolation as a form of vanity.
Luke 12:15Jesus' parable of the rich fool illustrates the 'vanity' of accumulating wealth solely for oneself, only to have one's life demanded back, mirroring the futility described in Ecclesiastes.
pooleEcclesiastes 4:7: "Then I returned, and I saw vanity under the sun."
No text from Poole on this verse.
ellicottEcclesiastes 4:7: "Then I returned, and I saw vanity under the sun."
(7) Then I returned.— The vanity of toil is especially apparent in the case of a solitary man. It is possible, as has been suggested (see Ecclesiastes 2:18 ), that this may have been the writer’s own case. The following verses, which speak of the advantages of friendship and unity, are of a more cheerful tone than the rest of the book.
This verse doesn't just present a general observation of futility; it's a specific turn in the Preacher's reflection. He's returning to his contemplation, and what he now sees is the profound emptiness of a life consumed by ceaseless, solitary accumulation, a drive for more that never finds satisfaction.
Solomon has just observed the futility of working endlessly without finding enjoyment, especially if one is alone. Now, he turns his attention to a different kind of emptiness: the endless pursuit of wealth by someone who has no one to share it with, not even family. This lonely, greedy individual toils relentlessly, yet never finds contentment, ultimately leaving it all to others.
Solomon has just observed the futility of working endlessly without finding enjoyment, especially if one is alone. Now, he turns his attention to a different kind of emptiness: the endless pursuit of wealth by someone who has no one to share it with, not even family. This lonely, greedy individual toils relentlessly, yet never finds contentment, ultimately leaving it all to others.
Get the original Greek and Hebrew, verse-by-verse context, and related passages inside the app.
Ask a follow-up
Ask Sola things like:
Live chat about Ecclesiastes 4:7-9 is available in the Sola app.
Such a person amasses riches, but to what end? The Preacher observes that this wealth often passes to 'distant relations or strangers' who offer no gratitude. The lifetime of striving yields no lasting, personal fulfillment or meaningful inheritance of love and care.
The Cost of Selfishness
The underlying issue highlighted is selfishness. When the drive is purely personal acquisition, it can lead to a state where 'there is none to take care of but himself,' and even that individual often denies himself rest in the obsessive pursuit.
"Again, I saw vanity under the sun: one person who has no other, either son or brother, yet there is no end to all his toil, and his eyes are never satisfied with riches, so that he never asks, “For whom am I toiling and depriving myself of…" — This verse doesn't just present a general observation of futility; it's a specific turn in the Preacher's reflection. He's returning to his contemplation, and what he now sees is the profound empti…
