The Preacher concludes that both paths, the blessed and the striving, ultimately lead to 'vanity.' How can this be?
The verse culminates with the sobering assessment: 'This also is vanity and a striving after wind.' This phrase, 'vanity of vanities,' appears throughout Ecclesiastes, signaling ultimate meaninglessness when viewed apart from God.
Earthly Endeavors' Limits
Even the wisdom, knowledge, and joy God gives in this life are ultimately temporary. They are gifts for our pilgrimage, not eternal possessions. They don't grant permanence or ultimate fulfillment in themselves, which is why they too can be seen as 'vanity' when pursued as the final goal.
The Futility of Apart-from-God Striving
For the sinner, the 'gathering and collecting' is inherently vain because it's done without God's blessing and without the capacity to truly enjoy it. It's a futile chase, like trying to grasp the wind.
God's Sovereign Hand
Underlying it all is God's sovereign hand. He is the one who distributes these different outcomes. The entire system, when viewed from an earthly, God-less perspective, appears as a cycle of striving and temporary satisfaction, ultimately amounting to nothing enduring.