Acts 19:40
For we really are in danger of being charged with rioting today, since there is no cause that we can give to justify this commotion.”
English Standard Version (ESV)
This page isn't yet indexed by search engines.
The town clerk, trying to calm the chaos, uses the word "commotion" to describe the riot, which is a much softer term than "sedition" or "riot." This subtle word choice downplays the severity of the situation, aiming to prevent the Ephesians from facing serious legal consequences from the Roman authorities.
A furious mob, stirred up by the silversmith Demetrius because their idol Artemis was being discredited by Paul's ministry, has just stormed the city theater. The town clerk, in a calculated move to de-escalate the dangerous situation and prevent Roman intervention, manages to calm the crowd. He then points out that they've brought no real evidence against Paul and his companions, and that this chaotic assembly leaves them all vulnerable to charges of sedition.
Imagine a massive, angry mob shutting down your city. What happens when the dust settles? Who faces the consequences?
The town-clerk of Ephesus understands that Roman law has zero tolerance for riots.
Legal Danger
He warns Demetrius and the craftsmen that their violent assembly isn't just a bit of public disorder; it's a serious offense. Roman law, he implies, could make them personally liable for this 'uproar' or 'riot.' This wasn't just a slap on the wrist – such disturbances could lead to the loss of their freedoms or even capital punishment.
No Justification
What makes their situation even worse is that they have no legitimate excuse. There's no real grievance, no valid reason for this massive, chaotic gathering. This lack of justification means they can't 'give an account' or explain away their actions to the authorities. They're on shaky ground, legally speaking.
Demetrius and his fellow craftsmen are upset, but is their anger truly about faith, or something else entirely?
The town-clerk’s skillful words reveal a deeper truth about the Ephesian mob.
Real Motive: Financial Loss
While the crowd shouts about the goddess Diana, the underlying issue for Demetrius and his craftsmen is economic. Their livelihood, making silver shrines of Artemis, is threatened by Paul’s preaching, which undermines their idol worship. The riot is a reaction to a threat to their business, disguised as religious fervor.
The Clerk's Political Maneuver
The town-clerk, a secular official, recognizes this. He doesn't defend the truth of Diana or Paul's message. Instead, he skillfully navigates the situation by appealing to civic pride and then by highlighting the legal danger. His goal is to calm the mob and prevent further trouble for the city, using their fear of Roman reprisal.
Understand the original words
stasis · Greek Noun
Refers to a tumultuous disturbance, public disorder, or insurrection. It implies a chaotic uprising of people against authority or civil order.
systrophē · Greek Noun
A state of unrest, confusion, or tumultuous activity. Biblically, it often denotes a lack of order or submission to God’s peaceful governance, standing in contrast to the orderliness expected in the kingdom of God.
This verse highlights the real political and legal dangers faced by early Christians. The town clerk's words remind us that the spread of the Gospel often stirred up societal unrest, leading to threats of official reprisal.
c. AD 50-52
Paul's Ministry in Ephesus
The Apostle Paul spends over two years in Ephesus, a major Roman provincial capital and center of pagan worship, teaching and performing miracles. This period leads to significant conversions and a decline in the business of silversmiths who create idols of the goddess Artemis.
c. AD 52— this verse
The Riot Erupts
Demetrius, a silversmith, incites a riot against Paul and his companions. He fears the loss of his livelihood as people abandon the worship of Artemis for Christianity, and he rallies other craftsmen with similar concerns.
c. AD 52
Town Clerk Intervenes
The town clerk, a civic official, calms the angry mob, reminding them of the potential legal repercussions from Roman authorities for such unlawful assembly and rioting.
c. AD 52
Paul Departs Ephesus
Following the riot and the ensuing danger, Paul is persuaded by his disciples to leave Ephesus. He travels to Macedonia, and later writes his first letter to the Corinthians from this region, reflecting on the severe trials he endured in Asia.
This verse demonstrates the Roman government's strict stance against public disorder by highlighting a similar law that prescribed the death penalty for sorcerers, which can be seen as a parallel to the legal repercussions for inciting riots, as mentioned by the town clerk.
2 Corinthians 1:8-10The Apostle Paul recounts severe afflictions and near-death experiences in Asia, strongly suggesting this Ephesian uproar was a significant event that threatened his life, mirroring the danger described in Acts 19:40.
Romans 13:1-7This passage establishes the divine authority of governing powers and the expectation that citizens should respect laws and order, providing a theological backdrop for why the town clerk was so concerned about the potential legal consequences of the riot.
1 Corinthians 15:32Paul mentions 'fighting with beasts at Ephesus,' which likely refers to this chaotic event, emphasizing the sheer danger and potential for violence that the town clerk sought to de-escalate.
pooleActs 19:40: "For we are in danger to be called in question for this day's uproar, there being no cause whereby we may give an account of this concourse."
He wisely minds them of their danger; for being under the power of the Romans, it was no less than the loss of their liberties to abet any faction or sedition; and to make a concourse or meeting tumultuously together, was capital, unless it were upon the sudden invasion of an enemy, or to but out some raging fire.
henryActs 19:32-41: "Some therefore cried one thing, and some another: for the assembly was confused; and the more part knew not wherefore they were come together."
19:32-41 The Jews came forward in this tumult. Those who are thus careful to distinguish themselves from the servants of Christ now, and are afraid of being taken for them, shall have their doom accordingly in the great day. One, having authority, at length stilled the noise. It is a very good rule at all times, both in private and publi…
The town clerk, trying to calm the chaos, uses the word "commotion" to describe the riot, which is a much softer term than "sedition" or "riot." This subtle word choice downplays the severity of the situation, aiming to prevent the Ephesians from facing serious legal consequences from the Roman authorities.
A furious mob, stirred up by the silversmith Demetrius because their idol Artemis was being discredited by Paul's ministry, has just stormed the city theater. The town clerk, in a calculated move to de-escalate the dangerous situation and prevent Roman intervention, manages to calm the crowd. He then points out that they've brought no real evidence against Paul and his companions, and that this chaotic assembly leaves them all vulnerable to charges of sedition.
A furious mob, stirred up by the silversmith Demetrius because their idol Artemis was being discredited by Paul's ministry, has just stormed the city theater. The town clerk, in a calculated move to de-escalate the dangerous situation and prevent Roman intervention, manages to calm the crowd. He then points out that they've brought no real evidence against Paul and his companions, and that this chaotic assembly leaves them all vulnerable to charges of sedition.
Get the original Greek and Hebrew, verse-by-verse context, and related passages inside the app.
Ask a follow-up
Ask Sola things like:
Live chat about Acts 19:40 is available in the Sola app.
c. AD 56
Paul Writes 1 Corinthians
While in Macedonia, Paul writes his first letter to the church in Corinth. He alludes to the intense pressure and danger he faced in Ephesus, describing it as being 'pressed beyond measure, beyond our strength, so that we despaired of life itself.'
"For we really are in danger of being charged with rioting today, since there is no cause that we can give to justify this commotion.”" — The town clerk, trying to calm the chaos, uses the word "commotion" to describe the riot, which is a much softer term than "sedition" or "riot." This subtle word choice downplays the severity of the…
