2 Samuel 17:7
Then Hushai said to Absalom, “This time the counsel that Ahithophel has given is not good.”
English Standard Version (ESV)
This page isn't yet indexed by search engines.
Hushai's seemingly simple statement, "This time the counsel... is not good," is actually a brilliant, subtle twist. He's not just disagreeing; he's strategically planting doubt by framing Ahithophel's past wisdom as the norm, implying this current plan is the anomaly and therefore likely flawed. This careful wording aims to undermine Ahithophel's authority in Absalom's eyes without directly confronting him.
David's son Absalom has just rebelled against his father and is now pursuing David, who has fled Jerusalem. Ahithophel, a former advisor to David, has given Absalom a brutal strategy to track down and kill David immediately. Hushai, who is secretly loyal to David but has stayed behind to pretend to serve Absalom, is now faced with the challenge of countering Ahithophel's deadly advice to protect David.
Ahithophel's advice had been gold before. So why was this time different? Sometimes, the best path isn't the most popular or the most logically sound on the surface.
The Difference a Name Makes
Ahithophel was legendary. In 2 Samuel 15:12, his counsel was so highly regarded that people thought it was like asking God himself. He was David's former advisor, a man who knew David's ways intimately. For Absalom, seeking Ahithophel's advice was a no-brainer, a sign of legitimacy.
But Hushai, another of David's loyal men posing as a traitor, recognized that Ahithophel's current plan, while seemingly brilliant for a swift victory, was actually deeply flawed.
Hushai wasn't just disagreeing; he was actively working to save the kingdom. His words reveal a strategic mind using discernment to counter a dangerous plan.
More Than Just a Second Opinion
Hushai's role was incredibly dangerous. He was undercover, a spy in Absalom's court. His goal wasn't just to offer an alternative, but to subvert Ahithophel's deadly counsel and buy David time to escape.
His strategy was brilliant:
Understand the original words
etsah · Hebrew Noun
A word or idea offered as guidance, advice, or a plan of action. In a biblical context, it often refers to deliberate strategies of men or the sovereign purpose of God.
Hushai's seemingly simple statement here is a masterstroke of political maneuvering. He's not just disagreeing with Ahithophel; he's strategically undermining a brilliant but ruthless strategist to save David's life and the kingdom.
c. 1000 BC
David's Reign Begins
David is anointed king and consolidates his power, establishing Jerusalem as his capital.
c. 995 BC
Absalom's Rebellion
Absalom, David's son, begins a rebellion against his father's rule, gaining popular support.
c. 995 BC
David Flees Jerusalem
David and his loyal followers are forced to abandon Jerusalem as Absalom's forces advance.
c. 995 BC
Ahithophel's Treacherous Counsel
Ahithophel, a trusted advisor to David, defects to Absalom and offers counsel to the rebellion.
c. 995 BC— this verse
Hushai's Counter-Counsel
This passage shows a similar instance where bad advice is given to a king, leading to disastrous consequences for his kingdom.
Proverbs 15:22This proverb highlights the danger of acting without wise counsel, echoing the potential outcome of following Ahithophel's flawed advice.
Jeremiah 18:18This verse shows how people can plot against prophets and wise counselors, paralleling Ahithophel's scheming and Hushai's counter-counsel.
1 Corinthians 1:20This passage speaks to God making the wisdom of the world foolish, which is exactly what happens when Ahithophel's clever plan is undone by Hushai's seemingly simpler, yet divinely guided, counsel.
Hushai's seemingly simple statement, "This time the counsel... is not good," is actually a brilliant, subtle twist. He's not just disagreeing; he's strategically planting doubt by framing Ahithophel's past wisdom as the norm, implying this current plan is the anomaly and therefore likely flawed. This careful wording aims to undermine Ahithophel's authority in Absalom's eyes without directly confronting him.
David's son Absalom has just rebelled against his father and is now pursuing David, who has fled Jerusalem. Ahithophel, a former advisor to David, has given Absalom a brutal strategy to track down and kill David immediately. Hushai, who is secretly loyal to David but has stayed behind to pretend to serve Absalom, is now faced with the challenge of countering Ahithophel's deadly advice to protect David.
David's son Absalom has just rebelled against his father and is now pursuing David, who has fled Jerusalem. Ahithophel, a former advisor to David, has given Absalom a brutal strategy to track down and kill David immediately. Hushai, who is secretly loyal to David but has stayed behind to pretend to serve Absalom, is now faced with the challenge of countering Ahithophel's deadly advice to protect David.
Get the original Greek and Hebrew, verse-by-verse context, and related passages inside the app.
Ask a follow-up
Ask Sola things like:
Live chat about 2 Samuel 17:7 is available in the Sola app.
Hushai's discernment wasn't just about seeing a flaw; it was about understanding the hearts of the people, the psychology of leadership, and the long-term stability of the nation. He used his wisdom to serve a higher purpose: protecting God's anointed king and preventing a catastrophic civil war.
David's loyal spy, Hushai, joins Absalom's court and subtly works to thwart Ahithophel's plans.
c. 995 BC
Ahithophel's Suicide
When his advice is rejected in favor of Hushai's, Ahithophel foresees the rebellion's failure and hangs himself.
c. 995 BC
Battle of Ephraim's Wood
Absalom's army is defeated, and Absalom himself is killed, ending the rebellion.
"Then Hushai said to Absalom, “This time the counsel that Ahithophel has given is not good.”" — Hushai's seemingly simple statement, "This time the counsel... is not good," is actually a brilliant, subtle twist. He's not just disagreeing; he's strategically planting doubt by framing Ahithophel'…
