2 Chronicles 15:17 Meaning Explained

2 Chronicles 15:17

But the high places were not taken out of Israel. Nevertheless, the heart of Asa was wholly true all his days.

English Standard Version (ESV)

Even though Asa didn't manage to completely get rid of all the idolatrous practices, God still saw his heart as fully committed to Him. This shows us that God's evaluation isn't always based on outward perfection, but on the genuine posture of our hearts towards Him.

What 2 Chronicles 15:17 means

After King Asa's incredible victory and spiritual reforms, the people, while outwardly compliant, secretly retained some of their old idolatrous practices in hidden places. Even though these "high places" weren't fully eradicated, the text emphasizes that Asa's personal commitment to God remained steadfast throughout his reign. This sets up a nuanced picture of leadership where outward success doesn't always mean complete eradication of sin, but personal integrity can still be deeply pleasing to God.

God's Standard: Wholehearted Devotion

We often think of faith as a simple 'yes' or 'no.' But what happens when the 'yes' is mostly there, but not entirely?

The Bible uses the phrase 'wholly true' or 'wholehearted' to describe a life fully devoted to God. This doesn't mean perfection, but a sincere, unwavering commitment of the heart.

What "Wholly True" Means

Unwavering Loyalty: It's about an inner allegiance that doesn't divide its focus. Think of it like a marriage vow – all in, no looking elsewhere.
Sincere Pursuit: It's not about flawless action, but a genuine desire to please God in every area, even when it's difficult.
Persistent Faith: Even when circumstances or people present challenges, the heart's true north remains fixed on God.

The Reality of Incomplete Obedience

Even the most godly people miss the mark sometimes. What can we learn from the 'high places' that remained?

The book of 2 Chronicles chronicles the reigns of Israel's kings. While Asa was a generally good king who made significant reforms, this verse points to a persistent issue:

Lingering Compromises

Cultural Baggage: The 'high places' were sites of idolatrous worship, often deeply ingrained in the culture. Removing them entirely would have been a massive social and religious undertaking.
The Limits of Human Reform: Asa could enforce changes, but he couldn't fully change the hearts of all his people or eradicate all traces of false worship. This shows the limitations of even righteous human leadership.
A Cautionary Note: This isn't to condemn Asa, but to show that faithfulness is often a messy, ongoing process, not a clean sweep. Even a 'wholly true' heart can coexist with incomplete outward obedience.

Understand the original words

Original language

high placesבָּמָה

bamah · Hebrew Noun

Local sites of worship, often located on hills or elevated areas. While initially used for sacrificing to Yahweh before the centralization of the cult in Jerusalem, they became heavily associated with syncretism and idolatrous practices and were consistently condemned by the prophets.

heartלֵבָב

lebab · Hebrew Noun

In biblical usage, the heart represents the inner self, the center of human intellect, will, emotions, and moral decision-making. Being 'wholly' or 'perfect' (shalem) denotes total devotion, sincerity, and undivided loyalty to God.

Historical context

Written: Likely compiled during the Babylonian exile (around the 6th century BC), reflecting events from the reigns of the kings of Judah.
Author: Traditionally attributed to Jeremiah the prophet, though its compilation likely involved multiple sources over time.
Location: Written from Judah, likely Jerusalem, during the period of the divided kingdoms.
Genre: Historical narrative with theological reflection, characterized by its chronological recounting of kings and key religious events.

Historical background

Asa's reign was marked by valiant efforts to purify worship in Judah, but the pervasive influence of the 'high places' – often centers of mixed worship – shows the deep challenge of complete religious reform, even for a king with a true heart.

c. 975 BC
Kingdom Divides
After King Solomon's death, the united kingdom of Israel splits into two: the Northern Kingdom of Israel (ten tribes) and the Southern Kingdom of Judah (two tribes, including Jerusalem). This division deeply impacts religious and political life.
c. 900 BC - 850 BC
Rise of High Places
Throughout both kingdoms, the worship of God often became mixed with Canaanite practices centered at various 'high places' – often hilltops or structures outside the central temple in Jerusalem. This syncretism became a persistent problem.
c. 873-848 BC
Reign of King Ahab
Ahab, king of the Northern Kingdom, became notorious for promoting Baal worship and persecuting prophets of the Lord, deepening the religious corruption of the era.
c. 814-798 BC
King Jehoahaz's Reign
Jehoahaz, king of the Northern Kingdom, continued in 'the sin of Jeroboam,' with significant religious compromise and oppression.

Key themes

01Incomplete reform efforts
02Unyielding devotion to God
03Inner truth over outward show

Cross-references

1 Kings 15:14

This verse directly parallels Asa's reign, highlighting that while he removed idols, the unofficial worship sites (high places) remained, showing that spiritual reforms can be incomplete.

Psalm 51:10

This psalm is a prayer for a 'clean heart' and a 'right spirit,' which echoes Asa's inward devotion despite external imperfections in the nation's worship.

Jeremiah 17:9-10

These verses describe the deceitfulness of the human heart and God's intimate knowledge of it, reminding us that true faithfulness is measured by the heart's allegiance, just as it was with Asa.

1 Samuel 15:22

Samuel's rebuke to Saul emphasizes that obedience and a wholehearted heart are more pleasing to God than outward sacrifices or rituals, a principle that resonates with Asa's sincere devotion despite lingering issues.

Frequently asked questions

What does 2 Chronicles 15:17 mean?

Explain the meaning of 2 Chronicles 15:17

What is the context of 2 Chronicles 15:17?

Study this verse in Sola

Get the original Greek and Hebrew, verse-by-verse context, and related passages inside the app.

Open in Sola app Get the app

Ask a follow-up

Ask Sola about this verse

Ask Sola things like:

“What does "high places" mean in the original Hebrew?”
“Why did Traditionally attributed to Jeremiah the prophet, though its compilation likely involved multiple sources over time. write 2 Chronicles 15:17?”
“How does incomplete reform efforts show up in 2 Chronicles 15:17?”

Ask in the Sola app Get the app

Live chat about 2 Chronicles 15:17 is available in the Sola app.

This page isn't yet indexed by search engines.

What 2 Chronicles 15:17 means

Original language

high placesבָּמָה

bamah · Hebrew Noun

heartלֵבָב

lebab · Hebrew Noun

Historical context

Written: Likely compiled during the Babylonian exile (around the 6th century BC), reflecting events from the reigns of the kings of Judah.
Author: Traditionally attributed to Jeremiah the prophet, though its compilation likely involved multiple sources over time.
Location: Written from Judah, likely Jerusalem, during the period of the divided kingdoms.
Genre: Historical narrative with theological reflection, characterized by its chronological recounting of kings and key religious events.

Historical background

c. 975 BC

Kingdom Divides

After King Solomon's death, the united kingdom of Israel splits into two: the Northern Kingdom of Israel (ten tribes) and the Southern Kingdom of Judah (two tribes, including Jerusalem). This division deeply impacts religious and political life.

c. 900 BC - 850 BC

Rise of High Places

Throughout both kingdoms, the worship of God often became mixed with Canaanite practices centered at various 'high places' – often hilltops or structures outside the central temple in Jerusalem. This syncretism became a persistent problem.

c. 873-848 BC

Reign of King Ahab

Ahab, king of the Northern Kingdom, became notorious for promoting Baal worship and persecuting prophets of the Lord, deepening the religious corruption of the era.

c. 814-798 BC

King Jehoahaz's Reign

Jehoahaz, king of the Northern Kingdom, continued in 'the sin of Jeroboam,' with significant religious compromise and oppression.