2 Chronicles 15:17
This page isn't yet indexed by search engines.
Even though Asa didn't manage to completely eradicate all the pagan worship sites, the most important thing was his heart's devotion to God. This shows us that genuine faithfulness isn't always about perfect outward actions, but a deep, unwavering inward commitment to God.
But the high places were not taken out of Israel. Nevertheless, the heart of Asa was wholly true all his days.
English Standard Version (ESV)
Following a stunning victory God granted him, King Asa initiated a sweeping religious reform, purging idolatry from Judah. However, this verse highlights a critical limitation: the ingrained worship practices in the northern kingdom of Israel remained untouched, a lingering spiritual compromise. Despite this incomplete victory, Asa's personal devotion to God remained unwavering throughout his reign.
Even the most faithful leaders can leave some things undone. Why was this the case for Asa, and what does it teach us?
The Limits of Reform
King Asa was a spiritual giant in many ways. He tore down idolatrous altars and commanded Judah to seek the Lord. Yet, this verse points out a lingering problem: 'the high places were not taken out of Israel.' These 'high places' were often sites of pagan worship, sometimes even syncretized with devotion to God.
This wasn't just a minor oversight; it was a significant spiritual compromise. It shows that even under righteous leadership, deeply ingrained cultural or religious practices can be incredibly difficult to eradicate completely. Perfection in reform is elusive, even for the best of kings.
What does it mean for Asa's heart to be 'wholly true'? Does it mean he was sinless or perfect?
True in Intention, Not Perfection
The phrase 'wholly true all his days' doesn't imply sinlessness. Instead, it speaks to Asa's unwavering intention and devotion to God. Despite the unresolved issue of the high places, his heart's primary allegiance, his deepest desire, and his consistent direction were towards the Lord.
This is a crucial distinction. It means faithfulness isn't about achieving an unattainable perfection, but about maintaining a sincere, resolute commitment to God, even when facing failures or ongoing struggles. Asa's heart was oriented towards God, even if his reforms weren't complete.
Ask a follow-up
Understand the original words
bamah · Hebrew Noun
Local sites of worship, often located on hills or elevated areas. While initially used for sacrificing to Yahweh before the centralization of the cult in Jerusalem, they became heavily associated with syncretism and idolatrous practices and were consistently condemned by the prophets.
lebab · Hebrew Noun
In biblical usage, the heart represents the inner self, the center of human intellect, will, emotions, and moral decision-making. Being 'wholly' or 'perfect' (shalem) denotes total devotion, sincerity, and undivided loyalty to God.
This verse highlights the tension between a leader's sincere heart and the persistent, deeply ingrained issues within a community. Even with significant reforms, the complete eradication of harmful practices can be a long, generational struggle.
c. 931 BC
Kingdom Divides
After Solomon's death, the united kingdom of Israel splits into two: the northern Kingdom of Israel and the southern Kingdom of Judah. This division fuels ongoing conflict and religious compromise.
c. 910 BC
Asa Begins Reign in Judah
Asa becomes king of Judah, a period marked by his efforts to reform religious practices and remove idolatry from the southern kingdom.
c. 908 BC
Asa's Military Victory
Asa achieves a significant victory over a massive Ethiopian army, strengthening his resolve and the people's trust in God. This victory allows him to further his reforms.
c. 907 BC— this verse
Asa's Major Reforms
Asa leads a sweeping religious reformation, removing idols and commanding Judah to seek the Lord. He even deposes his own grandmother for making an idol.
c. 907 BC
High Places Remain
Despite Asa's zealous reforms, the deeply entrenched 'high places' (local worship sites, often associated with paganism) are not completely eradicated throughout the land.
c. 873 BC
Asa's Death
Asa dies after a 41-year reign, remembered for his devotion to God, though not for completely clearing out all vestiges of idolatrous worship.
This passage highlights the same issue with Solomon's successor, Rehoboam, showing that even with good intentions, deeply ingrained religious practices were hard to fully eradicate.
Psalm 101:2This psalm expresses a desire for integrity and wholehearted devotion to God, mirroring Asa's internal commitment even when external reforms were incomplete.
Jeremiah 17:9-10These verses reveal the deep corruption of the human heart and God's discerning gaze upon it, underscoring the profound significance of Asa's inner sincerity despite outward imperfections.
Romans 7:18-19Paul's struggle with doing good and evil echoes the tension in Asa's reign, where the desire for righteousness (internal) clashes with the reality of persistent sin (external/societal).
Even though Asa didn't manage to completely eradicate all the pagan worship sites, the most important thing was his heart's devotion to God. This shows us that genuine faithfulness isn't always about perfect outward actions, but a deep, unwavering inward commitment to God.
Following a stunning victory God granted him, King Asa initiated a sweeping religious reform, purging idolatry from Judah. However, this verse highlights a critical limitation: the ingrained worship practices in the northern kingdom of Israel remained untouched, a lingering spiritual compromise. Despite this incomplete victory, Asa's personal devotion to God remained unwavering throughout his reign.
Following a stunning victory God granted him, King Asa initiated a sweeping religious reform, purging idolatry from Judah. However, this verse highlights a critical limitation: the ingrained worship practices in the northern kingdom of Israel remained untouched, a lingering spiritual compromise. Despite this incomplete victory, Asa's personal devotion to God remained unwavering throughout his reign.
"But the high places were not taken out of Israel. Nevertheless, the heart of Asa was wholly true all his days." — Even though Asa didn't manage to completely eradicate all the pagan worship sites, the most important thing was his heart's devotion to God. This shows us that genuine faithfulness isn't always abo…
Get the original Greek and Hebrew, verse-by-verse context, and related passages inside the app.
Last reviewed October 2026
