1 Timothy 5:23
No longer drink only water, but use a little wine for the sake of your stomach and your frequent ailments.
English Standard Version (ESV)
This page isn't yet indexed by search engines.
Paul tells Timothy to stop drinking only water, which might seem like a simple health tip. But the emphasis is on the word "only," suggesting that Timothy had been so disciplined in his asceticism that he was neglecting his own physical needs, something Paul, in his pastoral wisdom, saw fit to correct.
Paul is giving Timothy practical advice for navigating ministry, addressing both the spiritual health of the church and the personal well-being of his young protégé. Right before this, he's been instructing Timothy on how to handle church elders, and after this, he'll move on to the more serious matter of appointing overseers. This verse offers a gentle, human touch amidst these weighty instructions, showing that even spiritual leaders need to take care of their physical bodies.
Timothy was known for his spiritual dedication, but Paul's advice here suggests a surprising shift from extreme self-denial. What does this tell us about faith and health?
Paul's instruction to Timothy isn't about indulging in drink, but about practical self-care. It challenges the idea that spiritual maturity always means extreme asceticism or neglecting physical needs.
A Balanced Approach
Timothy, a young leader, was likely pushing himself hard. Paul, his mentor, offers counsel rooted in wisdom, not just spiritual fervor. The 'only water' implies a strict, perhaps unhealthy, regimen. The 'little wine' is a medicinal suggestion, acknowledging that physical well-being supports ministry.
God Cares About Our Bodies
This verse reminds us that God cares about the details of our physical lives. Our bodies are temples of the Holy Spirit, and taking care of them—even with simple remedies—is a wise stewardship. It's not about luxury, but about necessary support for sustained service.
Paul wasn't just a theological giant; he was a mentor who knew how to speak into the lives of those he discipled. How does this personal touch shape his message?
This verse showcases Paul's deep care for Timothy, not just as a spiritual son, but as a person with real physical struggles. He doesn't command, but advises ('use a little wine'), showing a pastoral heart.
Wisdom Over Legalism
Paul's advice is marked by discernment. He understands that Timothy's rigor might be counterproductive. Instead of imposing a strict rule, he offers a practical, nuanced solution. This contrasts sharply with rigid, legalistic approaches that ignore individual needs.
Personal Responsibility in Ministry
As a leader, Timothy needed to be healthy to effectively carry out his ministry. Paul's counsel underscores that personal well-being is not selfish but essential for faithful service. A healthy minister is a more effective minister.
This verse reflects the common understanding of wine's medicinal properties in the ancient world, contrasting with later, stricter ascetic views that sometimes arose in early Christianity.
c. 500 BC - 100 BC
Rise of Hellenistic Medicine
Medical understanding advanced significantly during the Hellenistic period, with figures like Hippocrates and later physicians cataloging diseases and treatments.
c. 300 BC - AD 100
Widespread Use of Wine in Roman Empire
Wine was a staple of the Roman diet, used for hydration, nutrition, and medicinal purposes. It was often diluted with water.
c. 40 BC - c. AD 90
Life of the Apostle Paul and Timothy
Paul, the likely author of 1 Timothy, was active in ministry during the mid-1st century AD. Timothy was his close associate, often experiencing health issues.
c. AD 60-65— this verse
Writing of 1 Timothy
The apostle Paul likely wrote this letter to Timothy while Timothy was serving as a leader in Ephesus, addressing practical issues of church life and leadership.
This passage also touches on wine, but in a cautionary context, highlighting the potential dangers of strong drink, which offers a contrast to Paul's practical advice for Timothy's health.
1 Corinthians 10:31Paul's broader principle here, that everything should be done for God's glory, echoes in his specific advice to Timothy, suggesting even personal health choices can be viewed through a lens of stewardship and serving God.
Philippians 4:11-13Similar to Timothy learning contentment with different circumstances, Paul himself learned to navigate needs and limitations, showing a life of adaptability that can inform how we approach physical well-being and practical advice.
Galatians 5:22-23While not directly about physical health, the fruit of the Spirit includes self-control, which is a relevant concept when considering how to manage one's diet and health responsibly, as Paul advises Timothy.
Paul tells Timothy to stop drinking only water, which might seem like a simple health tip. But the emphasis is on the word "only," suggesting that Timothy had been so disciplined in his asceticism that he was neglecting his own physical needs, something Paul, in his pastoral wisdom, saw fit to correct.
Paul is giving Timothy practical advice for navigating ministry, addressing both the spiritual health of the church and the personal well-being of his young protégé. Right before this, he's been instructing Timothy on how to handle church elders, and after this, he'll move on to the more serious matter of appointing overseers. This verse offers a gentle, human touch amidst these weighty instructions, showing that even spiritual leaders need to take care of their physical bodies.
Paul is giving Timothy practical advice for navigating ministry, addressing both the spiritual health of the church and the personal well-being of his young protégé. Right before this, he's been instructing Timothy on how to handle church elders, and after this, he'll move on to the more serious matter of appointing overseers. This verse offers a gentle, human touch amidst these weighty instructions, showing that even spiritual leaders need to take care of their physical bodies.
Get the original Greek and Hebrew, verse-by-verse context, and related passages inside the app.
Ask a follow-up
Ask Sola things like:
Live chat about 1 Timothy 5:23 is available in the Sola app.
c. AD 60-65
Concerns about Ascetic Practices
Some early Christian groups were beginning to adopt stricter, ascetic lifestyles, sometimes including abstaining from certain foods or drinks for spiritual reasons.
"No longer drink only water, but use a little wine for the sake of your stomach and your frequent ailments." — Paul tells Timothy to stop drinking only water, which might seem like a simple health tip. But the emphasis is on the word "only," suggesting that Timothy had been so disciplined in his asceticism…
