And he said to them, “The LORD is witness against you, and his anointed is witness this day, that you have not found anything in my hand.” And they said, “He is witness.”
English Standard Version (ESV)
Look closely at what Samuel does: he doesn't just say he's innocent, he calls God and His anointed (Saul!) as witnesses. This isn't just a legal formality; it's Samuel powerfully aligning himself with God's chosen king, even as he confronts the people's unfaithfulness.
And he said to them, “The LORD is witness against you, and his anointed is witness this day, that you have not found anything in my hand.” And they said, “He is witness.”
English Standard Version (ESV)
Samuel is standing before the Israelites at Gilgal, responding to their demand for a king, a demand he clearly sees as a rejection of God. He's just finished recounting all the ways God has faithfully delivered them throughout their history, and now he's asking them if they've found any fault in his own leadership. Their response, "He is witness," is a stark acknowledgment of his integrity, underscoring the unjustifiable nature of their request for a king over God's chosen leadership.
Samuel is making his closing statement, and he calls on God and His anointed king as witnesses. What does that really mean? It’s more than just a legal formality.
God as Witness
Samuel invokes the LORD as a witness against the people. This isn't just saying, 'God knows what I've done.' It's a solemn appeal to divine justice. It means that God Himself will judge the integrity of Samuel's ministry and the people's accusations.
The Anointed as Witness
He also calls upon God's anointed – referring to the newly appointed King Saul – as a witness. This is incredibly powerful. Samuel is placing his reputation not only before God but also before the very king the people desired, the king who would replace him. It’s a way of saying, 'Even the one you chose, who stands to benefit from my departure, can attest to my faithfulness.'
An Unshakeable Standard
By using these two witnesses, Samuel anchors his defense in the highest possible authority and the most immediate earthly representative. It leaves no room for doubt or future manipulation regarding his conduct.
The people have rejected Samuel's leadership and demanded a king. Yet, Samuel stands firm, not seeking personal gain, but vindicating his lifelong service.
The Accusation
Ask a follow-up
The underlying accusation from the people is clear: Samuel and his sons were corrupt, and a king would provide better leadership. They've essentially said, 'We want to be like the other nations,' implying that Israel's current system under Samuel was inadequate or unjust.
Samuel's Defense
Samuel's response, 'you have not found anything in my hand,' is a powerful declaration of personal and public integrity. He's not just denying theft; he's asserting a complete lack of wrongdoing, greed, or abuse of power throughout his tenure as judge and prophet.
A Legacy of Faithfulness
His defense isn't about self-glory. It's about demonstrating that the system he represented – God's ordained leadership – was righteous. By proving his own blamelessness, he implicitly points to the validity of God's dealings with Israel, even as they chose a new path.
After Samuel's powerful defense, the people don't argue. They simply agree: 'He is witness.' What does this brief, almost reluctant, affirmation reveal?
Acknowledgment, Not Repentance
The people's response, 'He is witness,' is a stark acknowledgment of the truth of Samuel's words. They know he hasn't wronged them. However, this isn't a confession of their own sin in rejecting God's established leadership.
The Weight of Their Choice
They are admitting Samuel's integrity, but they are also implicitly acknowledging the gravity of their decision to demand a king. They can't refute the evidence of Samuel's faithfulness, yet they still proceed with their desire for a monarchy.
A Moment of Truth
This brief exchange captures a critical turning point. Samuel has laid bare his faithful service. The people, though perhaps uneasy, confirm it. The stage is set for the consequences of their choice, with Samuel's integrity serving as a silent testament to God's past faithfulness.
Understand the original words
ed · Hebrew Noun
A person who observes an event or provides testimony regarding the truth of a matter, specifically invoked to confirm a covenant or a truthful declaration before God.
This moment unfolds during a critical transition in Israel's history, as they move from a theocracy led by judges to a monarchy. Samuel's defense of his integrity, under the solemn oath invoking God and the king (his anointed successor, likely David), highlights the gravity of his leadership and the people's potential for faithlessness.
c. 1070 BC
Saul Anointed King
Samuel, acting on God's behalf, secretly anoints Saul as the first king of Israel, marking a significant shift in governance.
c. 1050 BC
Saul's Rejection by God
Saul disobeys God's direct command during the battle with the Amalekites, leading to his rejection as king by Samuel.
c. 1050 BC
Samuel Confronts Saul
Samuel delivers God's judgment to Saul, stating that the kingdom will be given to another, more worthy person.
c. 1050 BC
Israel Demands a King
The people of Israel, despite God's warnings, persistently demand a king to rule over them, mirroring the surrounding nations.
c. 1050 BC— this verse
Samuel's Farewell Address
Samuel, nearing the end of his long service as judge and prophet, prepares to step down and addresses the nation. He recounts his faithful leadership and challenges their demand for a king.
c. 1050 BC
The People Fear the LORD and Samuel
After Samuel demonstrates God's power through thunder and rain during harvest time, the people are terrified and beg Samuel to intercede for them.
This passage echoes Samuel's appeal, presenting a stark choice between life and death, blessing and curse, emphasizing that Israel's decisions have eternal consequences.
1 Samuel 8:7Here, God tells Samuel that the people have rejected Him, not Samuel, highlighting the deeper spiritual rebellion that underlies their demand for a king and setting the stage for Samuel's defense.
Psalm 105:10-11This psalm speaks of God's covenant and promises to Israel, providing a divine backdrop to Samuel's assertion that he has upheld his end of the covenant relationship with God and the people.
Nehemiah 5:11-13Nehemiah, like Samuel, makes a public appeal to God and the people regarding his integrity and faithfulness, showing a recurring pattern of righteous leaders calling for accountability and divine witness.
Look closely at what Samuel does: he doesn't just say he's innocent, he calls God and His anointed (Saul!) as witnesses. This isn't just a legal formality; it's Samuel powerfully aligning himself with God's chosen king, even as he confronts the people's unfaithfulness.
Samuel is standing before the Israelites at Gilgal, responding to their demand for a king, a demand he clearly sees as a rejection of God. He's just finished recounting all the ways God has faithfully delivered them throughout their history, and now he's asking them if they've found any fault in his own leadership. Their response, "He is witness," is a stark acknowledgment of his integrity, underscoring the unjustifiable nature of their request for a king over God's chosen leadership.
Samuel is standing before the Israelites at Gilgal, responding to their demand for a king, a demand he clearly sees as a rejection of God. He's just finished recounting all the ways God has faithfully delivered them throughout their history, and now he's asking them if they've found any fault in his own leadership. Their response, "He is witness," is a stark acknowledgment of his integrity, underscoring the unjustifiable nature of their request for a king over God's chosen leadership.
"And he said to them, “The LORD is witness against you, and his anointed is witness this day, that you have not found anything in my hand.” And they said, “He is witness.”" — Look closely at what Samuel does: he doesn't just say he's innocent, he calls God and His anointed (Saul!) as witnesses. This isn't just a legal formality; it's Samuel powerfully aligning himself w…
Get the original Greek and Hebrew, verse-by-verse context, and related passages inside the app.
Last reviewed October 2026