1 Corinthians 14:34
the women should keep silent in the churches. For they are not permitted to speak, but should be in submission, as the Law also says.
English Standard Version (ESV)
This page isn't yet indexed by search engines.
This verse is often misunderstood as a blanket ban on women speaking in all church settings. However, the Apostle Paul is specifically addressing disruptive disorderliness in public worship gatherings, where women were to maintain a respectful silence to uphold order and decorum, not as a permanent silencing of their voices in all contexts. The emphasis is on how and where they are to express themselves, rather than a prohibition on their participation altogether.
Paul is addressing a chaotic situation in the Corinthian church where various spiritual gifts are being used in a disorderly way, hindering genuine worship and the spread of the gospel. This instruction about women speaking follows his extended discussion on how prophecy and speaking in tongues should be conducted orderly, and it's intended to bring a measure of peace and clarity to the assembly. The purpose is to ensure that everything is done for the building up of the church, not for personal display or confusion.
This verse can sound jarring to modern ears. What did Paul actually mean by 'silence' in the church?
Paul's instruction for women to 'keep silent' here isn't about a complete lack of voice, but about specific forms of disruptive speech. In the bustling, often chaotic environment of the Corinthian church, public order and respect were major concerns.
Orderly Worship
Paul was addressing disruptive behavior that undermined the worship service. This could include asking questions that interrupted the flow, engaging in debates, or speaking out of turn, which was not unique to women but applied to all in the community when disorder arose.
Role of Authority
The call for submission is tied to the idea of maintaining a proper order within the church gathering, which was a public demonstration. It's not about silencing their faith or intellect, but about regulating their participation to ensure edification and respect for the gathered community.
Ask a follow-up
Ask Sola things like:
Live chat about 1 Corinthians 14:34 is available in the Sola app.
Paul points to 'the Law' for his instruction. How did the Old Testament and the surrounding culture influence this teaching?
When Paul says 'as the Law also says,' he's referencing the broader principles found in the Old Testament and likely also the established cultural norms of the time.
Old Testament Principles
The Old Testament does lay out a framework for covenant community and public life that emphasizes order and specific roles. While not always directly commanding silence for women, the narrative and legal structures often reflect a patriarchal society where public roles were primarily held by men.
Cultural Context of Corinth
Corinth was a cosmopolitan city with diverse religious practices and social structures. In many ancient societies, including Hellenistic culture, public discourse was largely the domain of men. Paul's instruction here reflects a sensitivity to these norms, aiming to prevent the young Christian church from being perceived as chaotic or offensive, thereby hindering its witness.
Understand the original words
hypotassesthesōsan · Greek Verb
The voluntary act of yielding to an authority structure established by God, not because of inferiority, but for the sake of order and obedience to divine design.
nomos · Greek Noun
The Torah or the entirety of God's written revelation in the Old Testament, often cited as the foundation for moral and social principles.
Paul's directive for women to remain silent in churches, while challenging today, was given within a specific socio-cultural context in Corinth. It reflects a complex interplay of Jewish tradition, Roman social order, and the need for orderly worship as the early church navigated diverse cultural landscapes.
c. 200 BC - 175 BC
Maccabean Revolt Begins
A Jewish revolt against the Seleucid Empire, marked by intense religious and cultural clashes. This period saw a strong emphasis on upholding Jewish law and traditions.
c. 63 BC
Roman Conquest of Judea
Rome annexes Judea, bringing a new political and social order. Roman law and social customs, including distinct roles for men and women in public life, begin to influence the region.
c. AD 20-30
Jesus' Ministry and Crucifixion
Jesus' teachings and actions often challenged prevailing social norms. While women were followers and witnesses, the foundational leadership structure of the early church was male.
c. AD 40s-50s
Paul's Missionary Journeys
Paul establishes churches across the Roman Empire, often in diverse cultural settings. He encounters various social expectations regarding women's roles in public discourse and religious gatherings.
c. AD 50-52
Founding of the Corinthian Church
Paul establishes the church in Corinth, a major commercial and cultural hub known for its Hellenistic influences and often liberal social attitudes. This context likely contributed to various issues within the church community.
c. AD 55— this verse
Paul Writes 1 Corinthians
In response to reports of disorder and questions from the church, Paul writes this letter. He addresses issues of worship, spiritual gifts, and proper conduct to bring unity and order.
c. AD 90s
Later Pauline Epistles Written
Letters like 1 Timothy and Titus, also attributed to Paul, continue to address issues of church order and leadership, with similar directives concerning women's roles in teaching and public authority.
This passage echoes the theme of women learning in quietness and not being permitted to teach or have authority over men, directly supporting the sentiment in 1 Corinthians.
Genesis 3:16This verse describes God's pronouncement to the woman after the fall, indicating her desire will be contrary to her husband and he will rule over her, which provides a foundational Old Testament context for the idea of submission.
1 Corinthians 11:3-16Paul addresses head coverings and order in worship, discussing roles and the relationship between men and women in the church, offering a broader perspective on the cultural and spiritual considerations surrounding these issues.
Ephesians 5:22-24This passage instructs wives to submit to their own husbands as to the Lord, drawing a parallel between the wife's submission in the home and the church's submission to Christ, which informs the concept of submission discussed in 1 Corinthians 14.
This verse is often misunderstood as a blanket ban on women speaking in all church settings. However, the Apostle Paul is specifically addressing disruptive disorderliness in public worship gatherings, where women were to maintain a respectful silence to uphold order and decorum, not as a permanent silencing of their voices in all contexts. The emphasis is on how and where they are to express themselves, rather than a prohibition on their participation altogether.
Paul is addressing a chaotic situation in the Corinthian church where various spiritual gifts are being used in a disorderly way, hindering genuine worship and the spread of the gospel. This instruction about women speaking follows his extended discussion on how prophecy and speaking in tongues should be conducted orderly, and it's intended to bring a measure of peace and clarity to the assembly. The purpose is to ensure that everything is done for the building up of the church, not for personal display or confusion.
Paul is addressing a chaotic situation in the Corinthian church where various spiritual gifts are being used in a disorderly way, hindering genuine worship and the spread of the gospel. This instruction about women speaking follows his extended discussion on how prophecy and speaking in tongues should be conducted orderly, and it's intended to bring a measure of peace and clarity to the assembly. The purpose is to ensure that everything is done for the building up of the church, not for personal display or confusion.
"the women should keep silent in the churches. For they are not permitted to speak, but should be in submission, as the Law also says." — This verse is often misunderstood as a blanket ban on women speaking in all church settings. However, the Apostle Paul is specifically addressing disruptive disorderliness in public worship gathering…
Get the original Greek and Hebrew, verse-by-verse context, and related passages inside the app.
